Writer, book reviewer, lived experience advocate, independent scholar.
Writing about art, literature, disability, mental health, climate change
and the environment.
Wednesday, August 7, 2013
BOOK REVIEW: Call It Dog, by Marli Roode
What do you do when your estranged father gets in touch after ten years without contact asking for your help? That is what happens to twenty-three-year-old journalist, Jo Hartslief, when she returns to South Africa to cover the disturbances in Alexandria, a township near Johannesburg. After a decade living in the UK with her grandmother following the death of her mother, the country of her birth already feels alien to her. During her absence much has changed, on the surface at least, but dig deeper and it’s still a country struggling to come to terms with its complicated and bloody past. Jo undergoes a rollercoaster ride of complex emotions which force her to re-examine her sense of Self. Marli Roode valiantly mirrors this often painful journey in her story’s plot, exploring a father/daughter relationship gone sour down into its darkest and most disturbing crevices. In turn, both these internal personal interrogations act as a kind of literary reflector device to the very real atrocities still happening in the South Africa of the present day.
Roode narration of Jo’s experiences in the first person, as though they were entirely her own rather than being merely semi-autobiographical, emphasize her emotional pain, making it clear that Jo is not yet reconciled with her past. Similarly, calling her father, Nico, by his name adds to the deep sense of estrangement she feels towards him.
“I find him in Empangeni” is how Jo introduces her father to the reader. Her cool tone, devoid of any spark of pleasure, immediately establishes their distant, uneasy relationship. From the very outset they play a dangerous cat and mouse game of emotional manipulation, lies, and false assurances. Nico is clearly scared, but instead of telling her his story from start to finish, allowing her to fully assess his situation in order she may try to help him, he drip-feeds information in such a way that Jo has no way of knowing which bits, if any at all, are true. Her father explains that the police are after him for allegedly killing a black man and that he needs to show Jo exactly the spot where it is meant to have happened. They embark on a road trip during which he effectively kidnaps her. As they travel through the hot and unrelentingly barren landscape Nico drugs her bottled water, steals her phone and keys and Jo has the distinct feeling that if he goes down her father is determined that so will she.
Roode jumps back and forth in time between when she first arrived in South Africa on her journalist’s assignment, to almost the novel’s conclusion and then back to the developing story. This use of anachronism is sometimes a little confusing, but is probably meant to heighten the sense of tension and uncertainty. In this, the device is certainly successful.
The author does not spare the reader from the violence and bloody history of the country of her birth. She paints the political narrative of the contemporary South Africa which informs her novel in the crudest of brushstrokes, bringing home the point that although on the surface much has changed since the Referendum, beneath the veneer of equal rights for all, however, the situation is as dark and brutal as ever.
By the end of the book Jo is no closer to ‘knowing’ her father or the extent of his involvement in the murder. In fact, the mystery deepens when she wakes up in a hospital bed with no memory of how she got there. By going on what occurred during their road trip and through a degree of guesswork she pieces together what might have happened. Jo believes her father got scared and desperate enough to try and frame her for the crime he committed by staging an accident. While she is in hospital where the police can potentially find and question her Nico went on the run.
Once she has recovered Jo receives a further shock when she learns that the murdered man was the father of her friend and fellow journalist, Paul and his sister, Lindiwe. She begins to wonder whether Nico also had something to do with the car accident her mother died in. With their help she tracks her father’s last known movements and discovers that instead of owning and living in several comfortable country homes as he had told Jo, Nico, in fact, lived in squalor and poverty in a tiny flat without furniture. Amongst his things she finds proof of the kind of gruesome deeds her father might really be capable of.
The conclusion of Call It Dog feels a little desperate and cobbled-together, as though the author had suddenly lost the clear view of her storyline, but that is a problem many debut novelists and, on occasion, even very established writers grapple with. In no way, then, should the shortcomings of the last chapter or so of this book detract the reader from what is, ultimately, a brave and highly successful attempt to tell a difficult story set in the politically complex climate of South Africa at the close of the twentieth century.
REF: Call It Dog, by Marli Roode
Publisher: Atlantic Books, June 2013, 335 pages, pb
07/08/13
Tuesday, July 2, 2013
BOOK REVIEW: Imaginary Toys, by Julian Mitchell
Their milieu, 1950s Oxford, was one where class still mattered and where coming from a working class background or a wealthy one made all the difference between being a gentleman or an ‘ordinary’ man. The former, by his very status, automatically had a world of opportunities at his feet while the latter, even if he was of similar or higher intelligence, had to battle for every inch of his intellectually equal’s recognition. Even then he still fell short, simply because he did not have the ‘manner’ – that is, the bearing and confidence – of a gentleman.
Jack, a coalminer’s son, is the first in his family to go to university. He is in love with Elaine who struggles with her middle-class background and her Catholicism which forbids them to sleep together. Jack tries hard to understand the outlandish laws of her religion, but jealousy and his own insecurities always get in the way. Eventually, they come to realise that it is Elaine’s faith which has been blighting their happiness. They have been ‘acting’ the people they think they ought to be instead of being themselves.
Charles, the son of a wealthy lawyer, has an expensive sports car and is in love with the beautiful but cold-hearted Margaret. He tries to buy her love by acting as her chauffeur, always at her beck and call when she needs a lift and offering a series of romantic gestures which she crassly rejects. The confidence that comes as a ‘given’ to someone with his background gradually crumbles when, firstly, he fails in love and, later, when he comprehends that through his upper-class background he projects an unconscious arrogance to those less secure in their personal standing than himself.
Nicholas, a fellow student and a socialist, is gay. He writes at length about his various infatuations with other homosexual men. Often reciting whole conversations in an effort to clarify his feelings in his own mind, he ponders the different kinds of love: gay versus straight, platonic feelings towards someone of the same sex, against deep desire for the same. Nicholas symbolises the social conscience of his time. On the one hand he is the hidden ‘curse’ within society; the inadmissible ‘affliction’ which people would prefer did not exist and try to ignore before attempting to eradicate it through punitive laws and policies.
The literary influences of Mitchell’s early career are obvious. Firstly, those of Marcel Proust (1871-1922), in the novel’s long, almost out-of-control paragraphs with barely any punctuation which reveal the characters’ deepest emotions and moments of intense self-doubt. Secondly, Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited (1945) about class, religion and university life (albeit during the 1920s) seems to ghost the book’s pages. However, the author’s first exploration into prose fiction does not only look back into literary history in search of inspiration; it also acts as a significant stepping-stone towards his later achievements. In Imaginary Toys the reader can clearly detect the creative seeds of what is arguably Mitchell’s best-known work, his play Another Country (1981), based loosely on the life story of the Cambridge spy Guy Burgess. (Mitchell also wrote the award-winning screenplay when it was turned into a film three years later.)
The themes which occupy the thoughts, anxieties and complex emotional conundrums of the four main characters – class, social inequality, gay love, socialist politics and the struggle with religious conviction – are typical for the period and setting and mean that Imaginary Toys fills an important place in the post-war English novel. It is a delight to see it in print once more.
02/07/2013
Monday, January 23, 2012
BOOK REVIEW: Those Other Times, by Bess Ross
I AM ashamed to admit I had not come across the work of Bess Ross until now. She is acknowledged to be one of the finest Scottish writers today and I wish I had found her earlier. Her first novel, Those Other Times is semi-autobiographical and told in deceptively simple language. That is to say, the unadorned style of writing gives the story a very ‘immediate’ feeling which easily transports the reader to young Marjie’s side, the fourth of seven children. Although related in the third person her family’s struggles to make ends meet without money and in inadequate housing is effectively portrayed from Marjie’s point of view.
The novel begins with the arrival of the rent man while her father is still recovering from two weeks of illness which kept him in bed and unable to work. The rent man shows no compassion to their plight, giving the family until the end of the month either to find two months’ rent or leave their pleasant council home. Forced to return to the tiny damp abode in their father’s native island community the children make the best of their circumstances, enjoying being close to their grandmother who is able to provide occasional treats and brief reprieves from their chaotic home life. Cis, the children’s mother, prone to moods and unable to cope with bringing up her brood in these austere circumstances mostly takes out her temper on Marjie, but occasionally on her siblings too. Their father, John, keeps out of his wife’s way as much as possible by seeking refuge in his shed where he mends creels and fishing nets for other people.
Marjie, the brightest of the children, easily progresses from the village primary school to the nearby academy where she wins prizes for high achievement in Latin, French and Bible Studies. As they grow up Cis becomes increasingly resentful of her children’s education and the time it takes up. Time which, she says, would be far better spent getting jobs with wages to help keep the family afloat. While Marjie enjoys her studies and shares dreams with her friend, Margaret, of going to Edinburgh University in a few years time, she is also put under pressure to leave the academy, find work and contribute to the family income. When the day comes for her to depart for a new life in Edinburgh to work as a childminder she feels only relief.
Discovering this gem of a novel on the reading list for my postgraduate degree has been a delightful start to my journey along the highways and byways of literature of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland. I intend to seek out this author’s other books as soon as I have time and opportunity.
REF: Those Other Times, by Bess Ross
Publisher: Birlinn Ltd; 1991, 256 pages, pb
23/01/12
Monday, January 16, 2012
BOOK REVIEW: The Poisonwood Bible, by Barbara Kingsolver
IT was thanks to Faber generously offering my online book group The Lacuna as its first read shortly after it won the 2010 Orange Prize for Fiction that I ‘discovered’ in Barbara Kingsolver my favourite contemporary author. The Poisonwood Bible was the second of her books I read. Written a decade earlier I first of all noticed how her style had changed over this period. I enjoyed the opportunity to compare and contrast the very distinct shift in her writing. The later novel is mellower in tone, more lyrical, poetic even, and emotionally less raw. That is to say, by the time she came to pen The Lacuna the author was handling the conveyance of emotion more subtly which, instead of reducing its impact on the reader, makes it even more intense.
For me The Poisonwood Bible was a challenging and rather disturbing tale. What happens when one man’s controlling obsessive personality wrecks not only his own life, but also has serious consequences for his family may be fiction in this instance, but its gist will be frighteningly familiar to many. The story is character-led, a tool which Kingsolver skilfully employs to move the plot forward as well as providing real human depth as each character relates the situation from her own personal angle in alternating chapters. Nathan Price is the only character the author doesn’t give a voice to, a ploy which serves to emphasise the fact that Nathan is both the villain and victim of the story.
The female characters, Orleanna and her four daughters, are all remarkably well-drawn with Kingsolver paying great sensitivity to their plight of being forced to put up with the increasingly absurd ideas of their tyrannical husband and father. It surprised me, therefore, to realise partway through the novel that apart from describing his actions and behaviour towards his family and his congregation in that small African community Kingsolver fails to delve deeper into the mind of Nathan Price. In showing the way he spirals towards his unfortunate end she only deals with the effects of what is clearly a disturbed mind. She doesn’t, however, explore the reasons for it, the seed of which would have been planted long before.
The last third of the book in which the three remaining daughters (Ruth, the youngest having died from a snake bite years earlier) are grown up and are now following their own lives seems, to me, more like a sequel than part of the same novel. Although I think it's a nice touch to show what becomes of the women and how their experiences in Africa influence their later lives its writing feels less 'charged' somehow, as though the author took a lengthy break from the novel, maybe to work on something else, and returned to it when she was no longer quite so close to its subject and its characters. I'd be interested to know whether other readers share this sense.
The Poisonwood Bible is very ‘human’ and thought-provoking novel which lingers on in the mind long after the final page has been read.
REF. The Poisonwood Bible, by Barbara Kingsolver
Publisher: Faber and Faber, pb
At Home with Faber
16/01/12
Monday, August 23, 2010
BOOK REVIEW: The Lacuna, by Barbara Kingsolver
“In the beginning were the howlers. They always commenced their bellowing in the first hour of dawn, just as the hem of the sky began to whiten."
In achingly beautiful language Barbara Kingsolver tells the story of Harrison Shepherd, son of a feckless Mexican mother with a passion for dating powerful men and a dull American government accountant. Following their divorce she takes Harrison back to the land of her birth where he grows up lonely and without any early schooling. His education comes through reading some of the dusty old books in the domestic library of his mother’s lover, while through his only friend Leandro, the cook, he gains a penchant for food preparation which is to stay with him for the rest of his days.
The novel follows his course over a period of thirty years. The author skilfully shows how, in an era of political and artistic turbulence and uncertainty, Harrison is affected and changed by his experiences. Discovering early on his love of writing when he begins keeping a journal, it is in the form of diary entries that the reader accompanies him on his personal journey. Apart from a few minor ones the characters are superbly well drawn and the sense of location and time, particularly in the parts of the novel set in Mexico, are vibrant and almost strong enough to feel as if they’re rising up from the page.
Once a teenager his mother, Salome, sends Harrison back to Washington to live with his estranged father, who quickly dispatches him to a military academy. While there the young man witnesses the Bonus March of July 28th 1932. As a homosexual he avoids military draft, returning to Mexico where he resumes his employ in the household of muralist Diego Rivera and his wife, the painter Frida Kahlo as cook, having already done occasional plastering work for Rivera prior to leaving for the U.S.
Harrison becomes Kahlo’s confidant and when Trotsky and his wife arrive as permanent house guests he also acts as Trotsky’s secretary, meticulous typing up the reams of notes and articles he writes every day. After Trotsky is assassinated Harrison returns to the U.S. His life in Ashville, North Carolina is a fascinating portrayal of small town 1940s America. Here he turns his boyhood fascination with the Mexican Aztec into a series of best selling novels. His unexpected fame, however, sits uneasily with him until eventually his fear of public attention gains him the reputation of reclusive writer.
The relationship with his stenographer, Violet Brown, is handled with great charm and sensitivity. An enviable association of mutual respect and protectorship it provides a welcome antidote during the hostile climate of 1950s McCarthyism which Harrison unintentionally falls prey to and which ultimately leads to his untimely end.
Here is a remarkable writing talent, able to seamlessly weave real people and events into a fascinating fictional tale. I shall undoubtedly want to revisit this novel many times in the future and in the meantime look forward to correcting my unwitting omission of not having read any of Barbara Kingsolver’s work before.
REF. The Lacuna, by Barbara Kingsolver
Publisher: Faber and Faber (22 April 2010), 670 pages, pb
23/08/10
Saturday, May 22, 2010
BOOK REVIEW: Brideshead Revisited, by Evelyn Waugh
The Marchmains are a highly dysfunctional family. Each member is battling with their own emotional demons, insecurities and self-doubt. Waugh tells the story in beautiful language, almost poetic in places. He takes each character on his or her own personal journey. By the end of the novel each has undergone a transition of one form or another. Devoutly Catholic, the family’s faith rules their lives and controls all who come into contact with them. Even Charles Ryder, through whom the story is narrated, an agnostic prior to meeting the Marchmains, is in the end, unable to withstand its pull. This is evidenced, very subtly, in the last few sentences of the book when Charles goes to the chapel:-
‘There was one part of the house I had not yet visited and I went there now.
The chapel showed no ill-effects of its long neglect; the art-nouveau paint was as fresh and bright as ever; the art-nouveau lamp burned once more before the altar.
I said a prayer, an ancient, newly-learned form of words, and left.’
This aspect, that religious belief, particularly that of a Christian nature, can be so all-consuming and monopolising fascinates me and makes the discovery, of how dysfunctional a family the Marchmains really are, all the more shocking and disconcerting.
Charles meets Sebastian Flyte, the younger of the family’s two sons, in his second term at Oxford. They quickly form a strong bond and friendship which lasts several years. There is certainly an attraction between the two men, but the precise nature of their relationship is left open to speculation. Personally I find it appealing that I, as the reader, am allowed to interpret the affinity they share in my own way, rather than being told precisely. It adds an air of hushed mystery to the story.
I believe Charles feels an affection close to love for Sebastian. In fact, much later, when he has lost touch with his friend, but is forming a relationship with his sister, Julia, he admits as much. To Sebastian their friendship is, I think, more an escape from the claustrophobic atmosphere of wealth, custom and religion in which he was raised, but didn’t feel comfortable in.
The novel begins and ends twenty years later when Charles, having lost love, marriage and his children, returns to Brideshead as an army officer. The Marchmain’s former home is now an army camp. Only one of its previous occupants remains. Just as when Charles had met her during his first visit to Brideshead with Sebastian ‘on a cloudless day in June’ with which his recollections begin, Nanny Hawkins continues to live in the old nursery on the top floor, while the rest of the Castle serves as army barracks. In spite of how different the place is now and all that has happened to him in the intervening years, the drudgery of army life lifts from Charles’ shoulders as he contemplates the pleasure of being back at Brideshead for a time.
Charles Ryder and Sebastian Flyte are the most finely drawn characters in the novel. Waugh’s vibrant descriptions makes them step out from the page and stay with the reader long after the end. Some of the others therefore, especially Julia Flyte, who is no less important to the plot, appear a little two-dimensional by comparison. In contrast the protagonists’ fellow students, being lesser characters, are surprisingly vividly portrayed. The homosexual Anthony Blanche is so well depicted, in fact, that it’s easy to wish he played a greater role in the story.
REF. Evelyn Waugh : Brideshead Revisited ~ The Sacred & Profane Memories of Captain Charles Ryder Publisher: Chapman and Hall (1945 first UK edition), hb
22/05/10Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Debating Criticism
As well as poetry and journalism (early on in his career) George Mackay Brown wrote short stories, novels and plays. In fact GMB, as he was known to his friends and fans, is considered one of the most accomplished modern day short story writers not just in Scotland, but in literary circles globally, I believe. Reading them again I was struck once more by the strange concept, for want of a better term, of personal taste and/or opinion. Most agree that GMB's poetry is superlative, but opinion of his prose is fairly divided. Many pile on the praise, but there is a significant section of his readership who feels his characters are underdeveloped. To my own distress I lean towards the latter persuasion.
It's that devilish argument I so often have with myself all over again. Criticism: I know we all engage in it at some time or another, but is it ethically or morally justified? What right do I have to criticise the endeavours of others when I can't do what they do even half as well? And then there is the other aspect to this dilemma, or maybe it is actually the flip side of the same coin -- the ability (or not) to appreciate the qualities of something, wine or a work of art perhaps, even if one personally has no taste for it.
14/04/09
Monday, November 10, 2003
Author's Profile & Statement
The imagination is not an escape, but a return to the richness of our true selves; a return to reality. — George Mackay Brown (1921 - 1996)
I AM a writer, book reviewer and independent scholar residing in Orkney. I write short stories for adults and children and am currently working on a novel in each category. I also write poetry and have a keen interest in art and art history which occasionally inform my work.
I hold an MLitt in Literature (2013) from the University of the Highlands and Islands. In 2013 I won the inaugural George Mackay Brown Short Story Prize and was shortlisted in 2015.
My essays, reviews, short stories and poems have appeared in literary anthologies and journals, both online and in print.
Themes I explore in my writing include:-
* art and art history
* books and literature (classic & contemporary)
* creative writing
* identity & belonging
* disability
* place
* otherness
* climate change
* the environment
* nature and renewable resources
Member of the British Association for Contemporary Literary Studies
Blog
X
About
2026 is National Year of Reading Carola Huttmann I AM a housebound writer, book reviewer, lived experience advocate and independent...