Showing posts with label Environment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Environment. Show all posts

Saturday, June 30, 2018

Another Failure on the Road to Saving Our Planet

Friday, 22 August 2025

FOR anyone concerned about the devastating effects of climate — and, frankly, that should be all of us — it is indefensible that Governments and the large corporations which have the potential to influence measures to keep temperature rises below 1.5° of pre-industrial levels don't do more. Instead of taking steps towards reducing their organisation's carbon footprint, cut down waste and seek more sustainable ways of operating, they continue to manufacture plastics. fly their employees vast distances to attend overseas conferences which could easily be held online via platforms like Zoom or Microsoft Teams.

Instead of focusing on the harvesting of renewable energy, energy companies believe that building new nuclear power plants is the answer to our reliance on fossil fuels. Notwithstanding its detrimental aesthetic impact on the area, Hinkley Point C, in Somerset, for example, will, allegedly, provide energy to six million homes when it is up and running via its 3.2 gigawatt (GW) output. Of course there are always two sides to the coin. The construction of this and other nuclear power plants will create thousands of jobs. Government reports suggest that Hinkley Point C is estimated to bring £4bn into the regional economy as it replaces its predecessors Hinkley Point A, which ended production at the turn of the millennium and Hinkley Point B, which closed in 2023.

Countries that should be taking the biggest strides to stop further temperature rises are simply digging in their heels. It was inconceivable to me how the UN's COP28 conference (Conference of the Parties) could be held Dubai, the United Arab Emirates, the greatest oil producer in the world or that COP29 should have taken place in Baku, Azerbaijan, the world's largest carbon emitter. COP conferences, held each November, are attended by delegates from around two hundred countries. Accompanying them, inevitably, is their impossibly large posse of support staff, journalists, photographers and other assorted hangers-on. It's hard to ignore the outrageous hypocrisy. The elaborate time and carbon-intensive preparations and the number of flights and corresponding carbon footprint it takes to transport the people from all corners of the globe to discuss — wait for it — measures to reduce climate change. Events which, with today's available technology. could be held from delegates' offices or even their kitchen table via Zoom or Microsoft Teams.

Is it really surprising that the costs involved in staging COP conferences do not equate with the relatively minor success of discussions held? A bunch of exhausted, jet-lagged folk outside their comfort zones of their culture and home environment, distracted by the multitude of media reports varying in accuracy, personal messages from home or discomfort due to unfamiliar food. It's not a very reassuring mental image, but one that I believe is not too far fetched or unrealistic.

Hosted by the United Nation's Environmental Protection Agency, the latest abject failure of a major climate change event was the Plastic Pollution Treaty in Geneva, held in early August 2025. According to the UN, plastic production and waste is projected to triple by 2060, causing significant damage both the planet and human health. It was, therefore, devastating to read that the event ended without a deal being reached. As one diplomat put it: "the position of petrostates remains deeply entrenched and the US appears dead set against the creation of any new global agreement".

It remains to be seen what successes — or failures — COP30, held this year in Brazil (10 Nov - 21 Nov 2025) will bring. Personally, I don't hold out much hope that it will yield more realistic results than previous conferences have, but as an advocate for actively reducing the effects of climate change I have to keep hope alive. It's all and the rest of the world has.

_________________________________________________________

REFERENCES

Plastics Treaty talks collapse without a deal after “chaotic” negotiations
https://www.climatechangenews.com/2025/08/15/plastics-treaty-talks-collapse-without-a-deal-after-chaotic-negotiations
(accessed 22 August 2025)

Plastics Treaty negotiations end without agreement in Geneva
https://iucn.org/story/202508/plastics-treaty-negotiations-end-without-agreement-geneva-yet-many-countries-and-0
(accessed 22 August 2025)

_________________________________________________________

A Different Path

 

ALTHOUGH my potential journey to a PhD has been thwarted by insurmountable bureaucracy, I thought it would be fun for me — and perhaps for any interested readers out there in cyberspace — to document my route from my earliest encounter with my topic to (possibly) turning it into an academic monograph or even going the self-publishing route. The Introduction and first couple of chapters are already written although these will, undoubtedly, be revised and redrafted many times more along the way.

 Back, in what now feels to me like a long-distant past, but was in fact 1980, when I was twenty-one years old, my family had recently moved from the idyllic small town of Tring, in Hertfordshire, to the rather less pleasant (to put it mildly) suburban enclave of Harrow in Middlesex, north-west of the UK's capital. These days Harrow is referred to as 'Greater London', but is over an hour away from the centre by train — both overground and underground — and involves at least two changes; three if you want to go somewhere further from the city centre. About a mile and a half away from North Harrow lies the slightly more scenic village of Pinner, the pretty timber-clad houses along the High Street a reminder to its Tudor legacy. One train station away or about forty five minutes' walk, it is perhaps most famous as the birth-place of Sir Elton John and where he grew up and went to school. The house where he, allegedly, had ballet lessons as a very young boy was pointed out to me once. I am, however, unable to verify the accuracy of this claim. 

Pinner had, at the time at least, several charity shops which I would visit with some relish — not for the musty-smelling pre-loved clothes or dusty bric-a-brac, but for their eclectic selection of books. It was at one of these shops I first came across the work of George Mackay Brown. A slightly foxed but otherwise intact, copy of his volume of short stories, Hawkfall (1974) caught my attention. Reading the stories contained between its covers as soon as I got home I was intrigued. I was fascinated by Brown's simple, yet sensitive and uniquely lyrical depiction of hard-working farmers, fishermen and crofters. Who was this writer, residing in the distant Orkney Islands, that I had only the vaguest knowledge and understanding of at the time? I to find out more with an urgency that felt unaccustomed. 

As I discovered more and more about George Mackay Brown, the poet and writer as well as the man he was, I grew to have an ever greater affinity to him as a person and his traits although, as a writer, I sadly lack his remarkable gift for word-shaping and storytelling. Thus, with the unforeseen delight of that first collection of short stories purchased in 1980, began my preoccupation with Brown's literary oeuvre. It's an enchantment that will hopefully endure for the rest of my life. 

As for the mystery of that unfamiliar remote archipelago of islands, Dear Reader, I am thrilled to share that they became my home fifteen years after the story I have just told. I feel blessed, every day to have found peace and tranquility in this beautiful place, that has not only afforded me sanctuary from a past I'd rather forget, but has provided me with opportunities I never before experienced or imagined possible. 

I am pleased to witness the increasing number of authors who choose to address climate change in their fiction — for even in fiction there is always a grain of reality which gives the reader insight and pause for thought. As an independent scholar, not affiliated to any academic institution, I consider it a kind of privilege to be able to utilize the experience gained from studying for an MLitt in Literature at the University of the Highlands and Islands in 2012 – 2013 that affords me the ability to reason, research and write intelligently about a topic I feel passionate about. 

Just because I am no longer able to leave my home due to severely impaired mobility does not mean I don't want to support efforts to bring climate change under control, as much as it is still possible to do so at this relatively late stage. It is my generation's duty to ensure the sustainability of our planet for those who will follow in our footsteps. Sadly it won't make any difference to what is happening in the wider world, but in embarking on a new phase of my independent studies, I aim to build on my initial work on the Orkney poet and writer, George Mackay Brown (1921 – 1921), in which I shone a light on his first novel, Greenvoe (1972), exploring it from a Gothic perspective. 

My new phase of research will interrogate Brown's major prose works from an ecocritical standpoint, facilitating, specifically, further deconstruction of Greenvoe which, I believe, lends itself particularly well to ecocritism. It will also be an opportunity to consider his other novels in greater depth than I have before, as well as being a chance to address his position as a writer situated between two literary eras, those of the Enlightenment and Modernism and to examine how this influenced his output. 

Setting out my intentions publicly in this way will, I hope, serve me as motivation to accomplish my aims at some point in the future. Let's see how that pans out in the long term ....... 

16/01/2025

 ________________________________________________

A Bird's Eye View of Climate Change

 

CLIMATE change has occurred as long as human beings have roamed the Earth, as long as their thoughtless actions have influenced our planet's biodiversity — that is the balance, maintenance and sustainability of and between plants and animals. Commonly, climate change is deemed to have made the most significant impact since the start of the Industrial Revolution in the late eighteenth century, but altering weather patterns caused by mankind can be traced as far back as the Neolithic period (c.10,000 BC to c.2,000 BC) when a major shift in lifestyle took place, from a hunter-gatherer way of life to one of settlement and the introduction of farming. There can be no blame, of course, but ignorance and early experimentation meant the people of the Second (or New) Stone Age employed farming practices which exploited the land, rather than conserved it.

Mining not only produces high levels of carbon emissions, but through the creation of shafts also alters the balance of the soil. The ancient Egyptians dug for malachite and other minerals as early as 4000 BCE. In China evidence of coal mining can be found as early as 3490 BCE. In Ancient Greece coal mining began in the seventh century BCE and seems to have continued at least until the first century BCE. The Romans were the first miners in Britain, sourcing coal as well as metals like lead, copper, gold, silver, and tin, materials that were in high demand as the Roman Empire was established.

Now we are very nearly a quarter of a century into the new millennium, only the most hard-core individual will deny the obvious signs of climate change that we witness increasingly in all regions across the globe. Rising temperatures, an ever growing number of droughts, floods, hurricanes, tornadoes, the melting ice cap in Antarctica, the warming of our seas, alteration of acidic levels in our oceans.

Each successive COP conference promises so much, yet fails to deliver significant agreement between nations on the most effective measures, and the required finance, to prevent the world's carbon emissions rising by more than 1.5% on pre-industrial levels. Already scientists believe this is no longer possible and predict the figure could be as high as 2.5% or even 3% by the end of the century. As I wrote back in 2021, it seems incredibly hypocritical to fly thousands of people — government leaders, assorted supporting politicians, activists, journalists, etc. — a total of millions of miles to discuss …. wait for it …. CLIMATE CHANGE. This, in an age when we have the technology to remain in our usual locations and hold meetings via Zoom, Microsoft Teams or similar, sitting at a computer in our office or even at the kitchen table. It makes me angry all over again every time COP comes around. To add insult to injury, the last two events were held in what are known as 'petrostates', ie. countries whose economy is heavily dependent on the extraction and export of oil or natural gas. COP 28 was held in the Egyptian luxury resort of Sharm El Sheikh, while this year's COP 29 was in Azerbaijan's capital, Baku. In his opening speech, the OPEC Secretary General, Haitham Al Ghais stated that crude oil and natural gas were 'a gift from God'. With despicable, insular attitudes such as this, is it any wonder that the world is in the precarious situation it is?

Being housebound and neither a climatologist, environmental journalist or academic I only have a very small voice and limited ways in which to express my dismay at the harm mankind has been inflicting on the planet for millennia and its failure to comprehend the urgency of taking sufficient positive steps to prevent a catastrophic rise in temperatures through the use of fossil fuels and other carbon intensive activities producing greenhouse gasses and global heating. I do the best I can, as an individual of average intelligence, to employ critical thinking and read and learn as much as possible about the origins, effects and consequences of climate change. I live an eco-conscious lifestyle and shop only at small local independent shops where I know my food miles are minimal and my money goes into the local economy and not to some vast supermarket conglomerate already wealthy enough without my few meagre pennies. I'm a vegetarian, don't drive or own a dishwasher.

We all need to do everything possible to live sustainably and persuade governments, politicians and those in positions of influence to use their powers to instigate the tough measures required to prevent irreversible damage to our planet. Addressing the assembled delegates at the COP29 Climate Action Summit, the UN Secretary-General, António Guterres, urged leaders to take immediate steps to cut emissions, eliminate the use of fossil fuels and safeguard people from utter climate chaos. “Time is running out, but it is not too late,” he said.

It is our duty to ensure planet Earth is fit to live on for the generations who will follow in our footsteps. They deserve to know the environment at its best, be able to enjoy the flora and fauna and beauty that unspoiled nature offers. They do not need to suffer outrageous heat, devastating floods or failed harvests. They should not have to clean up the rivers their parents, grandparents or great-grandparents polluted or cope with the plastic detritus left by their elders. They didn't ask to be born, so they shouldn't be endowed with an apocalyptic legacy. In the words of the UN Secretary-General, “Time is running out,” so let's not waste any more. Let's repair what can still be salvaged.

24/11/2024

________________________________________________ 

John Muir: hero or anti-hero

Friday, 10 February 2023

“Only by going alone in silence, without baggage, can one truly get into the heart of the wilderness.”   — John Muir (1838 - 1914)

Like all controversial figures John Muir courted both admirers and detractors. Born in  the coastal town of Dunbar, midway between Edinburgh and the Scottish Borders, Muir was fond of nature and the outdoors from a young age, observing the bird- and wildlife in the countryside around his home. He grew up to become a naturalist, mountaineer, environmental campaigner and  writer, publishing over three hundred articles and a dozen books.

When he was eleven years old his family emigrated to Wisconsin, in America, to set up a farm. The third of eight children he was expected to feed and look after the animals and help with clearing the land and the annual planting and harvest of crops. After leaving Scotland he received no further formal education, because he could not be spared from the farmwork. His strict Calvernist father believed all necessary lessons came from the Bible and regarded studying or reading anything else as frippery.

But Muir was a driven man and taught himself mathematics, philosophy, geology and botany from books he borrowed from neighbours. He began inventing time pieces and other clockwork-operated implements to 'make people's lives easier'. When he was sixteen years old he went on his first train journey, travelling to Jamesville to display his homemade mechanical inventions at the Wisconsin State Fair. Six years later he finally left home for good and enrolled at the University of Wisconsin in Madison. Instead of doing a degree in a specific subject, he studied a variety of different modules pertaining to his particular interests in engineering and the natural sciences.

His love of wild spaces continued all his life and, as an adult, he made his name in conservation, establishing the worlds first national park system when he saved California's Yosemite Valley from being destroyed by developers hoping to build on the burgeoning popularity of tourism. Nowadays, of course, Yosemite National Park and others like it are set up to accommodate thousands of visitors every year, but preservation orders originally advocated by Muir ensure that the regions' wilderness areas remain as unspoiled and natural as possible. Muir also established the Sierra Club, an environmental non-profit organisation with branches, or chapters, all over America which campaigns for the protections of the country's areas of wilderness and natural habitats. He was its first president; an office he held for twenty years.

 Muir fell in love with Yosemite National Park the first time he visited and lived there for many years, working as a shepherd and mountain guide. It was here that he said he found his true religion. As the , James Hunt, writes in book Restless Fires (2012), “Many scholars feel that Muir’s baptism happened in California”.

As much as Muir was lauded for his environmental activism and writing in his own time and well into the twentieth century, in recent years political correctness and so-called 'wokeness' has somewhat tarnished the image of him as the hero who saved the wilderness in America and beyond. But, like all humans, he was a man of his time and was not without some flaws. The controversy around his personality appears to revolve around how he wrote and expressed himself with regard to the indigenous people. In today's terminology his remarks and attitude towards them would be seen as racist and abusive. While regarding nature and the creatures, large and small, within it, as a cathedral, he is said to have referred to Americans as subhuman, calling them: 'dirty', 'garrulous as jays', 'superstitious' and 'lazy'.

It is undeniable that Muir was a man of conflicts. It's debatable when and where his prejudices originated. I suggest there could be several possibilities. At its most elemental it could simply be ignorance about the kind of people those indigenous to America were. Alternatively, it could have been thoughtlessness about how he expressed his opinions, which negative as they were, would have been best kept to himself. Finally, it is possible that Muir was influenced by his father's Calvinist xenophobic attitudes which meant that anyone of a different faith or culture was to be feared and treated with extreme caution and even distaste. I would argue that this last is the most likely reason for Muir's views.    

In later years Muir did acknowledge some of his earliest prejudices and moderated his language when speaking about Indigenous people, even describing them in favourable light as, for  instance, in this lovely quote:-  

“Native American Indians walk softly and they hurt the landscape hardly more than the birds and squirrels.”

A further conflict in Muir's personality, particularly when viewed through a contemporary lens, lay in his penchant for machinery of all kinds and seeing the value in the new inventions offered by the Revolution which stood in direct opposition to his interest in the conservation and preservation of nature and open spaces. Even in this regard Muir was not consistent in his views, writing: "timber is as necessary as bread", thereby saying that it's permissible to fell trees for the purposes of house-building, heating and cooking, but not for clearing spaces for large-scale commercial development. Kat Anderson, an ecologist at the University of California in Davis, highlights another issue that was beyond Muir's control. As she explains:-

"The problem for Muir, for the National Park Service, for all of us, is that America was never a blank slate. And we know now Muir’s story was wrong. Native Americans in California, including those in Yosemite Valley, intentionally used fire to open land, increase pasturage, prevent even larger, more catastrophic fires and promote biodiversity. Muir’s sacred Yosemite was not a garden tended by God, as he wrote so passionately about — it was a garden tended by Native people."

It is also entirely possible that some of the damage to Muir's reputation occurred due to associations he made in the course of his travels and activism or when others writing about him  have misquoted him. His interactions with men of dubious integrity included the supremacist Joseph LeConte (1823 - 1901) and eugenicist David Starr Jordan (1851 - 1931). The most injurious of these wrongful attributions were claims about the 'removal' of Native American from Yosemite National Park made by another eugenicist, Madison Grant (1865 - 1937), not by John Muir. It is true that Muir was acquainted with Grant and Jordan, but he did not share their desire to allow only white settlers into the Park. In fact, he was fully alert to the destruction whites were capable of, as he wrote in his book, The Yosemite (1912):- 

“These temple destroyers, devotees of ravaging commercialism, seem to have a perfect contempt for Nature, and, instead of lifting their eyes to the God of the mountains, lift them to the Almighty Dollar.”                   

In My First Summer in the Sierra, written in 1911 and published five years later, Muir mused:-

“How many centuries Indians have roamed these woods nobody knows; probably a great many, extending far beyond the time Columbus touched our shores.”

Muir also noted how Indigenous peoples interacted with the landscape while living in harmony with nature, observing:-

 “By their fires they made talk to improve their hunting grounds and make it better for themselves and the wild animals.”

I would argue that these remarks show a deep respect for the original inhabitants of the Sierras and that it was merely his terminology in describing Native Americans which was unwise, but that in the course of his work he learned a lot and came to revise his opinions. 

It is unfortunate that the Sierra Club, which John Muir founded as an organisation tasked with protecting not only the natural state of America's wilderness areas, but also their history and legacy, should be one of the biggest culprits in denigrating Muir's efforts at conservation. Sullying his name by citing incorrect and unreliable sources, all in the name of misguided political correctness, goes against at least part of the Club's purpose, that of preserving history as well as the landscape.  History, after all, is rarely perfect. Instead of attempting to eradicate it simply because people find it unsavoury, it should be left alone so that past mistakes can be acknowledged and learnt from. 

With their emphasis on spirituality, it should come as no surprise that Muir was influenced by the thinking and work of Henry David Thoreau (1817- 1862) and Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803 - 1882). Not only did their ideas reflect Muir's own feelings about the natural world, but they were also an unconscious rebellion against his Calvinist upbringing. He argued that nature was a living, organic entity and it should be 's responsibility to look after it.
 
In conclusion, as someone who is passionate about looking after the environment and as we approach the 185th anniversary of his birth, I would like to advocate the celebration of the positives of John Muir's legacy. We must not forget that he was a man of his time and a product of his upbringing. Like all humans he was not without faults, but ultimately he was a hero, taking important steps towards preserving the wildernesses of his adopted country — a move which was observed and followed the world over.   

California celebrates John Muir Day on April 21 each year.

________________________________________________________

REFERENCES

Brune, Michael (2020) Pulling Down Our Monuments. Sierra Club, Washington, DC https://www.sierraclub.org/michael-brune/2020/07/john-muir-early-history-sierra-club (accessed 10 February 2023)

Colville, Mary  (2014) John Muir: The Scotsman Who Saved America's Wild Places. London: Lion Hudson Books  

Hunt, James B.  (2012) Restless Fires: Young John Muir's Thousand Mile Walk to the Gulf in 1867–68. Mason, Georgia: Mercer University Press

Mair, Hanson & Nelson (2021) Who Was John Muir Really? Earth Island Journal. Berkeley, California    https://www.earthisland.org/journal/index.php/articles/entry/who-was-john-muir-really (accessed 10 February 2023)

Muir, John (1916 & 1917) My First Summer in the Sierra. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin Company / The Riverside Press    https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/32540                               

Muir, John  (1912 & 1913) The Story of My Boyhood and Youth. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin Company / The Riverside Press   https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/18359             

Muir, John  (1911 & 1916) The Yosemite. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin Company / The Riverside Press     https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/7091

Muir, John     Wikipedia entry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Muir (accessed 10 February 2023)

Worster, Donald (2008) ‎ A Passion for Nature: The Life of John Muir. Oxford: Oxford University Press
________________________________________________________

Monday, June 25, 2018

POEM: A Story of Survival

 Sunday, 09 January 2022

The way the wind
sweeps the landscape
is not cruel and cold
but a caressing hand
watching, protecting

Nature is Earth's
lifeblood, like breath
is to mankind, essential
for survival, it shouldn't
be taken for granted

Sun, moon and the sea's
tides are its regulators,
its heartbeat that keeps
the Planet and its
inhabitants alive

Man needs to be kinder
to the land on which he
lives, to the air which he
breathes; think about the
generations which follow

How will they live if the
ecosystem has been destroyed?
They will not thank their
mothers and fathers, nor
their grandparents or their

Victorian ancestors who
were so keen on 'progress'
they started the Industrial
Revolution; they mined coal
to heat their homes and cook

They weren't the first; long
before folk could read and write
and records began, people polluted
their environment not knowing
any better, of course — back then  

Felling trees to build homes and ships
seemed practical — back then
but the damage was done, the land's
natural biodiversity disrupted; a
legacy that has passed down the ages

to the world we live in today. It's hard
to contemplate what the future
holds, but to be sure we'll be
living with the consequences
of man's actions of centuries ago    

© Carola Huttmann, 09 January 2022

 

Thursday, June 21, 2018

COP26 ~ Glasgow Climate Pact

Sunday, 14 November 2021

Overrunning its schedule by twenty four hours, COP26 concluded on Saturday. 13 November after two weeks of intense negotiations. It's final agreement is to become known as the 'Glasgow Climate Pact'. The main take-away message of the Conference by the exhausted, emotional COP President Alok Sharma was: "..... we have kept 1.5C alive. But, its pulse is weak and it will only survive if we keep our promises and translate commitments into rapid action." He ended the Conference's closing speech by telling delegates:-

"Crucially, countries promised to 'revisit and strengthen' their 2020 climate goals by the end of 2022. This is the moment of truth for our planet, our children and our grandchildren.”

In his speech, António Guterres, reiterated that further urgent work was needed, saying:-

“Our fragile planet is hanging by a thread. We are still knocking on the door of climate catastrophe. It is time to go into emergency mode – or our chance of reaching net zero [emissions] will itself be zero.”

So, what are the key points agreed in the Glasgow Climate Pact?

  • In a surprise announcement, the US and China promised to work together to limit the global temperature rise to 1.5C within the next decade

  • More than 100 world leaders promised to end and reverse deforestation by 2030, including Brazil, home to the Amazon rainforest

  • The US and the EU announced a global partnership to cut emissions of the greenhouse gas methane by 2030 - reducing methane in the atmosphere seen as one of the best ways to quickly reduce global warming

  • More than 40 countries committed to move away from coal - but the world's biggest users like China and the US did not sign up

  • Some new pots of money were announced to help developing countries adapt to climate change and deal with the damage and loss it brings - but many say it's not enough

  • A new alliance that commits countries to setting a date to ending oil and gas use - and halting granting new licences for exploration - was launched

Furthermore, new rules were established, allowing for greater transparency in the reporting of emissions. Arguably, the most significant commitment was the eventual elimination of coal power and inefficient fossil fuel subsidies by countries which, to date, rely heavily on them. In a television interview Alok Sharma explained that this was the first time there had been "explicit mentions of coal and fossil fuels in any UN climate agreement". He stressed that some of the wording used in the final agreement remained controversial, particularly for those countries whose economies currently rely on carbon emitting resources. They are points which will require further negotiations over coming years in order to meet the satisfaction of all countries.

COP27 is due to be held in the Red Sea resort of Sharm El-Sheikh, in Egypt from 7 to 18 November 2022. It remains to be seen whether further action to limit the Planet's climate change can be agreed on there.


Wednesday, June 20, 2018

COP26 ~ Action on Climate Change

Friday, 12 November 2021

Youth activists should be admired and supported in urging action to protect our Planet from further damage, but it must be their elders — scientists, governments and other relevant bodies — who enforce and implement regulations to elicit action. Without this help young people can only do so much. It is, after all, the baby boomer generation, the mothers, fathers, aunts and uncles, which is responsible for the highest carbon emissions since the Industrial Revolution. It is also they who have the power to mandate changes in behaviour and implement the strictest of rules to curb further climate damage. Youngsters are justly concerned about the kind of future they will inherit if not more is done to stop emissions, end greenhouse gases and phase out the burning of fossil fuels. It is the young people of today and the generations which follow that will have to deal with the consequences which reckless human behaviour has had over past decades and centuries.

To anyone observing COP26 from the outside, the Conference may have appeared to be a lot of grand political posturing. The young activists protesting on the streets of Glasgow certainly think so. Amongst the tense negotiations and the tentative commitments made — some more so than others — there will undoubtedly be a degree of what Greta Thunberg calls 'greenwashing' from the leaders who want to (in fact need to) be seen to make ever more fervent pledges to ensure the country they represent actively reduces its carbon emissions.

While opinions about the success of COP26 appear to vary widely, it is perhaps not the abject failure that some had predicted prior to the event following the negotiations by G20 Summit in Rome in the lead up to COP26 in Glasgow. Although it is indisputable that much still needs to be done in terms of securing finance from the world's richest nations to support the most vulnerable countries, agreements on abandoning oil and gas and the transition to renewable energy, significant commitments have been made in respect to reversing deforestation, and the cutting of carbon and greenhouse gas emissions. There have also been unexpected commitments made by India for reducing its use of coal by 2070 and a pact between the US and China to work together to limit global temperature rises to the 1.5C level recommended by the so-called 'Paris Agreement' in 2015. But, whilst trying to focus on the positive, there is also a lot of understandable doom-mongering. On Friday, 12 November, the last scheduled day of negotiations the Secretary General of the United Nations, António Guterres, said that COP26 will probably not achieve all of its aims in limiting global warming to 1.5C of pre-industrial level. As Guterres puts it, "the world is on life support".

 

Sunday, June 17, 2018

Brain Pollution

 Saturday, 2 October 2021

Most people understand that air pollution — the exhaust fumes from cars or foul smoke belching from factory chimneys, for instance — has a detrimental effect not only on the Planet, but on our health too. Yes, our lungs are arguably our most vulnerable organs when we breathe in dirty air, but our brains, also, are affected by what we absorb through our nose and skin.

What has not been talked about until now, is what is known as brain pollution. This contamination, however, is not carried on the air, but like air it is all around us. It's advertising! Think about it. Whenever you walk down a city street your senses are bombarded by it. Brands shouting — metaphorically — from shop fronts, from billboards above stores, from advertising hoardings built for the purpose and even from the walls of derelict buildings. Lights from tower blocks and shopping centres endlessly flash well-known names at you as you pass. Impossible to ignore. They penetrate our vision and consciousness even when we're not actively thinking about brands or materialistic things. The stimulus of this unceasing barrage of advertising causes havoc in our brains. Homo sapiens are not made to cope with such high concentrations of visual and mental stimulation without respite. The brain needs time to absorb and process what the eyes see. If there is too much it can lead to health problems, everything from visual disturbances to depression, as well as more serious mental instability. The result of this assault of advertising is brain pollution.

Advertising urges us to buy into the latest fads, follow the latest trends and purchase the latest gadgets on the market. The aim is to convince us that we cannot do without this 'stuff', these brands that are supposedly so cool and desirable, as I have already discussed in a previous post. Advertisers depend on our positive response to what we see on billboards, on TV or in the media. If reaction is mostly negative the advert is deemed to have failed to do its job.

In manufacturing these highly sought-after items, which advertisers try to make us believe are so delectable, factories up and down the land discharge high levels of carbon emissions. As the infectious diseases specialist and television presenter, Dr Chris Van Tulleken explains:

"The brain pollution of advertising creates not just the high-carbon lifestyles feeding the climate emergency, but also a wave of commerciogenic diseases ranging from malnutrition to depression. Yet this is one of the least talked about and understood aspects of the climate and public health crises."

The more people become preoccupied with gadgets and materialistic goals and values, the less they care about how their materialism affects the environment. The development of digital technology has created an entirely new market, called the 'attention economy', in which advertisers treat human attention as a commodity to be competed for.

The advertising market is growing exponentially. What it, like the consumers it targets, doesn't take into account is that by promoting overconsumption and people's desire for superfluous, non-essential goods it is contributing significantly to the destruction of the Planet. The most damaging advertisers are, of course, those in the motoring, aviation and energy industries. There is a lot of greenwashing going on in all of these. It has been suggested that governments and local authorities should call for an end to high-carbon advertising. The process for removing harmful adverts is, however, extremely cumbersome. Since there is currently no adequate legislation in place it relies entirely on people's willingness to take action. Until something more is done by those who have the power to influence law-makers and governments we are destined to continue being victims to brain pollution.

 

Road to Hell
some thoughts about COP26 and Climate Change

 Thursday, 30 September 2021

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that the climate crisis needs to be addressed — urgently. The statistics are stark and dangerous proof that without action we are approaching dangerous territory. We need to do what we can to halt the further apocalyptic destruction of our planet. In fact, I would argue, that historically we have gone far too long without attempting sufficient damage limitation. After all, it is human activity which is to blame for inflicting such gross harm upon the environment.

If scientists and politicians agree that it is so imperative to cut down on carbon emissions, I ask myself why they are hell-bent on creating a massive carbon footprint by flying delegates from 196 countries to attend the UN Conference on Climate Change to be held in Glasgow between 31 October and 12 November 2021. Of course these representatives will not be travelling alone. They will be accompanied by their respective entourage, as well as journalists and television crews of the countries from which they hail. I cannot be the only one who is struck by the enormous hypocrisy at play here. These people, who believe themselves to be an authority on climate change, are presumably all highly intelligent individuals. Have they learned nothing from what the Coronavirus pandemic has taught us about what is possible? IT technology has become increasingly sophisticated over the past twenty years. In this period video conferencing has been recognised as being convenient and reliable. Zoom calls are now part of our everyday lives. Humans are adaptable creatures and we have become used to talking to our colleagues and friends online. I appreciate that not everyone has the space they would like but, mostly, we have grown accustomed to the convenience of working from home.

Much has already been written about the reappearance of insects and wildlife in our gardens, parks and woodland due to the presence of fewer exhaust emissions as people used their cars less during the various lockdowns imposed. For a long time, also, fewer flights were taken than in pre-Covid days. These are things to be celebrated, yet I believe that the overall savings in carbon output which the reduction in such activities has brought about remains underreported.

Personally, I think man's efforts to do anything significant that will contribute to limiting the harm we are inflicting on our planet should be shouted from the rooftops and reported in every media outlet available to us. To see someone doing their bit to help save the environment will motivate others to do what they can themselves. The old cliché 'keeping up with the Joneses' isn't only about material gain that will put us on a par with our friends and neighbours. In the twenty-first century it has taken on a new meaning. We are collectively encouraged to recycle, shop more wisely, reduce our use of plastics, cut down on our meat intake and generally live more sustainable lives. Unfortunately, the term's former definition is also still being kept alive by online influencers attempting to induce young people to desire and buy material things they don't need, but believe are essential to keeping up with others in their peer group. Extolling the importance of further developing wind and water energy, making driving electric cars the new norm and continuing to promote the benefits of cycling whenever possible will go at least some way towards ensuring future generations will have a sustainable environment in which to live, grow and thrive. But it is not enough.

We hear and read, with frightening regularity, about extreme temperatures causing massive wildfires in California, Greece, Russia, Australia and elsewhere which destroy thousands of miles of terrain, wrecking crops and grassland and endangering lives and livelihoods. In other regions, such as Germany, Turkey and even in London, unusually intense rainfall is doing the same. Rising temperatures at the North Pole causes ice floes the size of Great Britain to melt, threatening the lives of polar bears and other creatures for which the region is home.

Some environmentalists argue that climate change began as early as 12,000BC, when the Neolithic Revolution began to have an impact on the Earth's resources. The way humans utilised the land affected its biodiversity and ecosystems. Cutting down trees for house building and firewood altered a region's biodiversity and, over the following centuries, brought about changes in the weather. In modern times the effects of climate change intensified with the Industrial Revolution. Smoke belching out from factory chimneys, turned the air hazy and grey in the process of manufacturing goods that would make our lives easier and richer, financially as well as intellectually and materially. Although coal mining has taken place in Britain since Roman times in a more primitive form, the way we think of it today really took off, in all parts of the UK — Scotland,Wales and sites around northern England — during the early 1700s and continued for the next 270 years before seeing a decline. Coal fuelled steam engines, heated people's homes and created jobs. It is an industry which altered the lives of everyone living in Britain during this period. The invention of coke in the early eighteenth century further increased the release of carbon into the atmosphere. Each additional development for the convenience of mankind brought more damage to the environment — aeroplanes, motor cars, ships, refrigerators, washing machines, the manufacture of plastics and other non-biodegradable materials. The list is endless.

In August 2021 the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) published its sixth Assessment Report. It makes depressing reading. Produced by hundreds of the world’s top scientists it claims the climate crisis is unequivocally caused by human activity and is evident in every region around the globe. Climate change, the report says, cannot be reversed. The damage already caused is so great that it can only be mitigated by a small degree. If present levels of carbon emissions were maintained it would get much worse. Action to keep global heating below 1.5 celsius has to be taken immediately. This is the danger level specified in the International Treaty on Climate Change, the so-called 'Paris Agreement', adopted at the UN Conference on Climate Change (COP21) in December 2015.

The IPCC report further tells us that globally sea levels have already risen by twenty centimetres and are likely to continue rising. Melting ice in the Arctic, pouring trillions of tonnes of water into the world's oceans, is creating an imbalance in the oceans' levels of oxygen and acidity. Carbon dioxide levels in the air are now at their highest for at least two million years. As if all that were not shocking enough, we're told that fossil fuel burning and the destruction of forests are contributing to the unprecedented rise in temperatures witnessed all over the world. Incidents of flash flooding have become more frequent since the 1950s, affecting more than ninety percent of the world’s regions. Drought is increasing in regions from Africa, to Asia and South America. The number of major hurricanes and typhoons recorded around the globe has risen by an estimated sixty six percent since the 1970s.

Back in 2015 few eyebrows will have been raised at the news that delegates and their entourages from 196 countries around the world were jetting into Paris to talk about .... erm .... climate change. Six years ago face to face diplomacy was still deemed acceptable and necessary. Every delegate attending world conferences like this one, or the G7, G8 or G20 summits, will tell you that many of the most important points of negotiations are hammered out, not in the main hall with hundreds of other people present, but in small side rooms outwith the main conference. Now, however, we have the shared experience of the Covid pandemic. Video conferencing technology has shown what can be achieved without adding to the global carbon footprint. Zoom and Microsoft Teams facilitate so-called 'break-out rooms' to enable separate discussions, away from the main event. We know it can be done. The onus rests on every single one of us. Surely, climate change professionals ought to be the first to embrace the possibilities which new technology offers. The world needs to act before it is too late. Excuses and playing for time are no longer acceptable if we wish to give our children, grandchildren and great grandchildren the lives they deserve. But then, with a government that appears less than fully committed to setting out the roadmap by which the necessary reductions in carbon emissions may be achieved, what hope do we realistically have?

I realise that one insignificant individual holding forth on the hypocrisy of several hundred people getting on planes to fly to Glasgow to attend COP26 which — at the time of writing — is a month away, is not going to make any difference, but it feels cathartic to be doing so. If just one person reading this essay is given pause to reflect on the reality of what I have said, it will have been worth my while. I wish I had the power to do more to stop COP26 from going ahead in Glasgow and convincing its organisers to hold it online, but sadly I don't. Does it help knowing I am doing the best I can to contribute, in a small way, to halting further exacerbation of climate change? Not really. Besides what I already do — not owning a car, a television, a dishwasher, not buying new clothes, turning my domestic heating on only when absolutely necessary to keep pipes from freezing in winter, not eating meat, keeping my waste to a minimum and recycling what I can, there is little more I can do. I am only one small voice, one individual, living on a small Scottish island. An island that is brim-full of talent. Art, crafts, music all flourish here, but perhaps most impressive of all is the innovative exploration of wind and tidal energy that happens here. More people here drive electric cars than elsewhere in the UK. I would love to have the power and influence to save the world. As that is not possible I shall quietly relish my good fortune at being able to call Orkney home and, along with the rest of the world, try to keep the faith and hope it will divert us from the road to Hell.

________________________________________________________

NOTES

IPPC sixth Assessment Report

https://www.ipcc.ch/assessment-report/ar6

Full Report    https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1

Closing the Gap: The Impact of climate Commitments on Limiting Temperature Rise

https://www.wri.org/research/closing-the-gap-g20-climate-commitments-limiting-global-temperature-rise

_________________________________________________________


Saturday, June 16, 2018

Greenwashing

 Saturday, 11 September 2021

Definition: Greenwashing is a marketing tool employed by companies to give consumers the illusion they are doing more to help protect the environment than they are.

The term was first coined in 1986 by the American environmentalist Jay Westerveld, when he was asked to reuse a towel in a hotel in order to, supposedly, reduce water usage.

One of the areas in which Greenwashing is most prevalent is in the fast fashion industry. The young environmental campaigner, Greta Thunberg is probably not the first to have written about this, but perhaps she is the most high-profile. In an interview for the Scandinavian edition of Vogue Magazine in August this year she claims that she hasn't bought any new clothes for three years and those she bought before then were second-hand. I don't mean to denigrate her claim, but I can beat her record (if that is what it is). I haven't bought any clothes for the last fifteen years, but then I am three times as old as she is and no longer growing. Nor am I fashion-conscious, a fact that some might consider a serious flaw in my personality.

The fast fashion industry isn't the only one which uses Greenwashing tactics to coerce the public into believing it's helping to save the planet. The worst offender, arguably, is the oil industry. Let's face it, oil excavation and deep-sea mining will never be activities that don't damage the Earth's resources. Yet BP and others would like to convince us that their operations increasingly use greener methods. Well, if that isn't Greenwashing the facts, I don't know what is. And, don't even get me started on the issue of burning fossil fuels. Perhaps I am extremely naïve or overly critical — or maybe it's a bit of both — but I find it hard to believe that the carbon emissions produced can be adequately contained, despite multiple claims of the proliferation of carbon capture plants around the world. Are these storage facilities really equipped to do the job properly? Not to mention the fact that building such plants is eyewateringly expensive.

I am willing to be persuaded that in using carbon capture plants it is possible to keep carbon emissions below 1.5% as recommended in the so-called 'Paris Agreement', negotiated at COP21, the UN Climate Change Conference, in December 2015, but in the meantime I remain unconvinced that these plants adequately meet the job description and that sufficient other measures are being taken to limit carbon emissions across all industries worldwide. There is still an awful lot of Greenwashing around but, hopefully, the public's increasing awareness of the damage carbon emissions are doing to our planet is making it more critical of companies claiming to do more to protect the environment than they are. I say: "no more Greenwashing, please!"

____________________________________________________

NOTES

Greenwashing (Wikipedia)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenwashing

Greta Thunberg: ethical fast fashion is ‘pure greenwashing’https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2021/aug/10/greta-thunberg-ethical-fast-fashion-greenwashing?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=facebook&fbclid=IwAR2tcbMlSCjIERmDRI7SjiUIi0Yl0le5Ec9JNw8jIx_SWL3B6Da_yLD9dQ8_

What is greenwashing? Everything you need to know about fashion’s faux sustainabilityhttps://www.womanandhome.com/us/fashion/greenwashing-fashion-guide/

The Disastrous Effects Of Greenwashing You Need To Knowhttps://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/greenwashing-effects

UK’s largest carbon capture project to prevent equivalent of 22,000 cars’ emissions from polluting the atmosphere from 2021 (Gov.UK)

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/uks-largest-carbon-capture-project-to-prevent-equivalent-of-22000-cars-emissions-from-polluting-the-atmosphere-from-2021

Paris Agreement (Wikipedia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Agreement

 World’s biggest machine capturing carbon from air turned on in Icelandhttps://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/sep/09/worlds-biggest-plant-to-turn-carbon-dioxide-into-rock-opens-in-iceland-orca

____________________________________________________


Saturday, April 7, 2007

Sham or Scam

IT seems to me that there is still far too much confusion and controversy about what is causing climate change. Almost everyone is in agreement that it is happening. Indeed, it's taking place incredibly quickly. Even to the most uninitiated it must be obvious that our weather is different now to just a decade ago. The uncertainty then, lies in whether global warming is due to man's inconsiderate abuse of the environment or whether perhaps humanity is only partly to blame and that the main cause of greenhouse gases is to be found in nature itself.

Harm to the environment cannot be caused by just one phenomenon. It is the result of two or more events within nature impacting upon one another. Unfortunately, global warming as a concept is being driven by a most powerful machine, that of money. While we, the public, are encouraged to recycle our rubbish, walk to the shops instead of using the car and take no more than one holiday abroad a year, it is scientists who are pawns in the game of 'call my bluff'. Through research grants provided by governments they are persuaded to provide us with proof (as if we need it) that the environment, as we know it, is changing. The evidence is to put the blame squarely at our door. It is our actions, our overblown lifestyles which will forever alter the world if we don't mend our ways forthwith. Politicians are the marketeers who ultimately try to drive the message home to us honourable citizens of the world. They spout big words and threats hoping to scare us all into changing the way we live our lives. They allocate funds to specific target areas or projects where they believe the finance can be used most influentially. It is known, for example, that in her drive for nuclear power Margaret Thatcher allocated money to scientists to provide concrete proof that the burning of coal and oil was harmful.

It could be, however, that the first phase of what we are seeing today actually began around eight hundred years before a measurable rise in CO2 levels was first noticed. We already know there is evidence that over many millions of years the Earth’s temperature has fluctuated between markedly warmer and colder periods. It was one of the former which probably sparked the increase in CO2 levels while the Earth was heating up rather than being the cause of it.

The real truth about climate change is that we don’t yet know a great deal. We have a lot of facts, a lot of theories and much evidence that it is happening all around us, but we still have a long way to go before being able to fully explain it and consequently know how to effectively induce damage limitation. In the meantime it remains a topic of much controversy, debate and rhetoric, but worst of all it is a huge money spinner. Millions, which would be better spent on feeding the poor and looking after the old and the disadvantaged at home and abroad, are being spent on staging conventions in exotic locations, promoting foods and products which will allegedly save the environment and lining the pockets of politicians. It’s not news that it’s the innocent and the vulnerable which will be the worst off wherever they happen to live on this Earth.

07/04/07

Monday, March 26, 2007

Catch 22

LISTENING to the current Chancellor’s last budget the other day as well as following the subsequent fallout in all parts of the media I was struck, not for the first time, how contradictory so many aspects of modern life are. It really boils down to the fact that most are ‘no win’ scenarios. There are no perfect solutions to any of them. Telling us that we all need to be greener and punishing those who are (apparently) unwilling or unable to comply probably serves only to make the Chancellor himself feel better. The rest of us may be more able to weigh up the ‘for and against’ and realise there will be a price to pay whichever way it goes.

The following comparison may seem a little strange perhaps, but the debate over what steps we need to take to limit further damage to our planet reminds me of an old and well documented argument. Is drinking decaffeinated coffee and tea really that much more harmful than indulging in the regular stuff? Some will advocate that it definitely is, whilst others are less certain when they learn how the process of extracting the caffeine actually works. In a nutshell it involves a procedure which is both complex and costly and depending on the particular method used may end up imbuing the beverage with more toxic materials than it extracts.

There is, of course, no doubt in my mind that protecting the environment is vital if we want to leave a legacy to our children enabling them to have a good future, but since there is no one right solution, we must decide how we are going to, at least, find the correct balance.

So, we are dissuaded from flying more than, say, once a year. But how will this affect the airlines? More considered use of cars, particularly 4 x 4s is advocated with the result that the already burdened car industry is likely to feel even more threatened. We are encouraged to travel more by public transport – buses and trains, that is, not planes. Where are we going to find the extra time from in our already hectic schedules? We also know that time is money.

We are told to install solar panels on our roof to trap what little sunshine we get in this country and hope it will generate enough heat to keep us cosy over the winter months and provide us with a constant supply of hot water. But, what about the cost and bother of installing said panels? We should have a wind turbine in our back garden and sell back to the national grid the electricity we get from it which is surplus to our requirements. What about all those ensuing sleepless nights when we lie awake listening to the constant whirring and whooshing coming from outside? Whole wind farms could one day be dotted across our green and pleasant land like a major outbreak of the measles. No longer will we be able to let our eye roam unobstructed over an undisturbed and beautiful landscape. Just like many moons ago, when miles upon miles of electricity pylons snaked their way across the countryside like a weary, disorientated army of soldiers our view, in the future, will be similarly interrupted..

All this is well and good until we come to ponder the effects some of our ‘green’ initiatives will have upon the economy and on inter-continental relations. Are the high flyers of the business world really going to be penalised each time they jet across the Atlantic for a meeting? Any organisation, whatever its size, whatever its success would find excessive charges like that difficult to sustain over the longer term. Sure, the countries we do business with share our interest in damage limitation from climate change. We can but hope that they will be just as concerned as we are to find an answer to how we can best maintain global trade links. In other words, by asserting our determination to protect the environment from further devastation we are, at the same time, potentially taking several steps back when it comes to supporting the economy.

In the end, I guess, the ‘green’ issue will remain controversial for a long time to come, perhaps even forever. It’s all about compromise and finding a balance we can live with.

26/03/07

About

  2026 is National Year of Reading      Carola Huttmann I AM a housebound writer, book reviewer, lived experience advocate and independent...