Keywords
Poetics, Politics, Art, Twenty-First-Century Literature,
Experimental Literature, Collage
How to Cite
Huttmann, C., (2020) “BOOK REVIEW ~ DRAG,Wojciech Collage in
Twenty-First Century Literature in English”, C21 Literature:
Journal of 21st-Century Writings 8(1). doi:
https://doi.org/10.16995/c21.1989
AS Wojciech Drag notes in this new study, Collage in
Twenty-First Century Literature in English, collage is an act of
violence followed by active repair (23). The initial deconstruction
is the cutting or tearing involved in the making of a collage. The
making good is the pasting required to create something new and to
give it the ‘strangeness’ or otherness that is the definition of
collage. For art or a text to qualify it has to be, at least in part,
appropriated and be constituted of ready-made materials. These
factors, in turn, must be juxtaposed or rearranged in some way that
is different from their original state (ibid). The complexity of the
resulting work demands from its audience a greater engagement than
might ordinarily be the case so that intellectual sense can be made
from it. In the light of this premise Drag quotes Rona
Cran, who states that collage is an ‘invitation to participate’
and to be ‘experienced’ (21).
The fact that the book’s tagline is ‘Art in Crisis’ is
significant. Already in his introduction, Drag explains how critics
are lamenting ‘the death of the novel’ (Will Self) and the danger
of print publications being displaced by electronic literature and
audiobooks (5). The texts of each of the writers Drag discusses tell
a story of a kind of crisis. In most cases it is of a personal
nature: loss, grief, heartbreak, a subversion of the writer’s or
main protagonist’s sense of self. Intertwined with the ideas
explored, are also aesthetic, sociopolitical and cultural concerns of
the twenty-first century: fashion, consumerism, capitalism and the
influence of social media. Furthermore, it is the innovative manner
in which these authors present their work, as fragments of
appropriated quotations placed amidst lots of white space on the
page, indicating conflict, hesitation and confusion, being joined
together in alternative ways, which demonstrates the collage-like
nature of what they have created.
Drag divides his study of Collage in Twenty-First Century
Literature in English into three parts, bookended by an extended
Introduction and a Conclusion. The Introduction is subdivided into
sections in which Drag examines the history of collage in art and
literature, the poetics of collage, the politics of collage, and the
scholarly assessment of collage-like literary texts. In this section
he also investigates the theories of multimodality, that is the way
in which texts convey their meanings through semiotics. Finally, in
his Introduction, Drag looks at textual coherence through Rhetorical
Theory Structure (RTS), with its focus on author intention.
Collage, as an art form is believed to have been the invention of
the Cubist movement with Pablo Picasso (1881–1973) and Georges
Braque (1882–1963) regarded as the first exponents of the form.
Drag explains that the term, derived from the French word, coller,
to ‘paste’ or ‘glue’, can also be French colloquialism for
‘having an affair’ or ‘living in sin’ (10). This notion,
then, of daring and co-existence is the theory behind collage. The
Surrealist, Max Ernst (1891–1976), another advocate of collage,
supposedly called it ‘the coupling of two realities’ (ibid). Made
up of a series of nonsensical woodcuts with short subtitles, the
first collage novel was Ernst’s book-length narrative, La femme
100 têtes (1929) (14). Drag describes collage as a product of
the social, economic, aesthetic and philosophical conditions
prevailing in the early twentieth century (15). In literary texts the
ready-made element of collage usually takes the form of quotes or
images, both attributed and unattributed. That is certainly the case
in the texts Drag discusses in the book under review.
Collage has frequently been employed as a political vehicle. The
anti-Nazi photomontages of the visual artist John Heartfield
(1891–1968) are just one such example (25). The Russian avant-garde
artists who flourished between 1890 and 1930 also used collage to
promote their anti-capitalist sentiments (ibid). Less extreme, but
equally forceful, is the use of collage as a response to the rise of
consumerism – think of the work of Andy Warhol (1930–1987) and of
some of the Abstractionists, such as Willem De Kooning (1904–1997),
Jackson Pollock (1912–1956) and Mark Rothko (1903–1970) (26). To
illustrate a literary example, Drag cites the American artist and
critic, Gwen Raaberg (b.1932) as a prime proponent of writing about
collage, not only in the context of visual art, but as having a
place, too, in feminist literature (25). Modernist poetry, says Drag,
depended on the fragmentary nature of collage far more than the
novel. The most often cited passage of modernist poetry being the
concluding eight lines of The Wasteland (1922), in which
T.S. Eliot juxtaposes excerpts from seven sources (28).
All but one of the authors Drag reviews are American.
Unsurprisingly, perhaps, the definition of collage – the idea of
appropriation, use of ready-made materials and their juxtaposition to
create something new – means that there is some overlap in the way
these writers create their literary works.
In Part 1, subtitled ‘Art in Crisis’, Drag examines the late
novels of David Markson (1927–2010).
In his lifetime Markson created a rich oeuvre of work, but due to its
unconventional, experimental nature his name only gained wider
recognition after his death. Critics regard his last four books as a
tetralogy, connected as they are by Markson’s method of cutting,
pasting and juxtaposing fragments of quotes and random text to form
their narratives (48). The books, all quite short – between 150 and
200 pages – are Reader’s Block (1996);
This is Not a Novel (2001); Vanishing Point (2004)
and The Last Novel (2007).
Drag analyses the nature and source of many of the fragments
making up the four Markson novels he studies, attempting to explain
their function in order to make sense of their meaning and purpose.
About the last one cited in the previous paragraph, for example, Drag
explains that it concerns Auden’s assessment of the German poet
Rainer Maria Rilke (1875–1926) and is one of several hundred
quotations Markson used in his narrative which are biographical or
encyclopedic in nature (51).
Part II is titled ‘Society in Crisis’. In it Drag assesses two
multimodal short stories by the experimental writer, Lance Olson
(b.1956) and co-authored with the writer’s wife, Andi, from his
collection, Sewing Shut My Eyes (2000)
as well as two of Olson’s novels, Head in Flames (2009)
and Dreamlives of Debris (2017).
The author of fourteen novels, four collections of short stories and
numerous instances of co-authored works of non-fiction, Olson’s
writing has become increasingly collage-like over the last twenty
years, incorporating hybrid black and white images reminiscent of
graphic novels with the focus on juxtaposition and multimodality
(99).
As Drag explains, the stories making up Olson’s collection,
Sewing Shut My Eyes, came to be associated with the movement
known as Avant-Pop which encouraged non-linear writing and is thought
to have signalled the end of postmodernism in literature (100).
‘Telegenicide’, a short story from Sewing Shut My Eyes
is concerned with the shallow nature of celebrity culture and is a
comment on the influence of television on American society. It
features seven top female models remarking on the pain they have to
endure to keep their shape and the pressure the fashion industry puts
on them. The accompanying images, or ‘panels’ created by Olsen’s
wife, Andi, are finished off by Olsen with slogans taken from
commercial adverts for Coca-Cola, Pepsi and the US Army. The panels
show television screens in different contexts. One of them is an open
mouth with white teeth which, Drag notes, ‘resemble plastic bags
packed with cocaine’ (106). In his analysis of ‘Telegenicide’
Drag refers to the work of the French sociologist, philosopher and
cultural theorist, Jean
Baudrillard (1929–2007) and his essay, titled ‘The Ecstasy of
Communication’, in which Baudrillard writes that ‘advertising
invades everything as public space disappears’ (149). ‘Dreamlives
of Debris’ is a retelling of the Minotaur myth and features forty
characters, among them Sophocles, Plato, St. Augustine;
contemporaries such as Julian Assange, Bradley Manning and Edward
Snowden and mythical figures like Ariadne, Daedalus and Odysseus who,
by way of appropriated citations, address themes which, Drag
explains, are especially relevant to life in the twenty-first
century: disease, cataclysm, chaos and conflict (115).
‘Head of Flames’, inspired by the murder of the Dutch
film-maker, Theo Van Gogh by Muslim fundamentalists in November 2004,
tells the story of his death in incomplete sentences from the view
points of three narrators: Vincent Van Gogh, Theo Van Gogh and Theo’s
murderer, Mohammed Bouyeri. These POVs are made up of quotations from
Heinrich Heine, Strindberg and Julian Barnes and are occasionally
interspersed with lines from popular songs, by singers such as Cher
and Britney Spears (111). Olsen has Theo Van Gogh humming passages
from Spears’ song ‘Hit Me Baby One More Time’ as he cycles to
the scene of his murder (ibid). As in his short story,
‘Telegenicide’, Olson’s focus in ‘Head of Flames’ is on the
anxieties that make up twenty-first century life, its traumas,
discontents and the influence of social media (118).
Part III is titled ‘The Self in Crisis’ and is an assessment
of Graham Rawle’s novel, Woman’s World (2006), which
Drag calls ‘the quintessence of collage literature’ (159). Rawle
is a British writer and collage artist whose visual work incorporates
illustration, design, photography and installation. His series, ‘Lost
Consonants’, which explored the comic effects of letters being
omitted from sayings or quotations, appeared weekly in the Weekend
Guardian between 1990 and 2005. Other series, such as ‘Lying
Doggo’ and ‘Graham Rawle’s Wonder Quiz’, were published in
The Observer, The Sunday Telegraph Magazine and The
Times (ibid). His first novel, The Diary of an Amateur
Photographer (1998),
is a multimodal murder mystery comprising images, newspaper clippings
and some cut up text placed in an envelope at the end of the book
(ibid).
Woman’s World is a huge undertaking for which
Rawle spent seventeen hours every day for five years cutting up
women’s magazines from the 1950s and 1960s, finding single words,
whole chunks of text and small images and arranging them to tell the
story of Norma Fontaine who lives in a perfect woman’s world of
handy tips and sensible advice. Whether it is choosing the right
foundation garment or practising feminine allure through meticulous
grooming, Norma measures her life, and the people in it, by the
standards set out in the magazines she reads (160). Drag describes
Woman’s World as ‘radical in its reliance on
appropriation’, since it is ‘composed entirely of external
elements’ (167). Ultimately, the novel represents an image of ‘the
self immersed in, and defined by, consumer practices’ (170).
In the conclusion to Collage in Twenty-First Century
Literature in English Drag points out that despite the
similarities in the methods of creation and even, on occasion, in the
content and sources used, each of the works reviewed ‘have been
shown to vary in their incorporation of the collage principle’
(205). Drag reminds us that although the purpose of collage in art
and literature during the second half of the twentieth-century was to
shock and provoke its audience, in the last two decades collage has
become much more of an artistic and aesthetic form of expression
(208). Furthermore, advances in digital technology and the rise of
electronic literature and ebooks have enabled the creation of more
daring multimodal literature (209). More generally, each chapter ends
with a comprehensive list of notes and works cited. Drag’s research
and analysis of the texts he chooses to examine is meticulous and
exhaustive. Writing in the first person imbues his material with a
sense of ownership that is both bold and reassuring. The book also
manages to be eminently accessible to non-academics interested in
learning about the use of collage as a way of creating innovative
contemporary literature.
Competing Interests
The author declares that they have no competing interests.
References
Baudrillard, Jean. 1983. ‘The Ecstasy of
Communication’ (tr. John Johnston). The Anti-Aesthetic: Essays
on Postmodern Culture, ed. Hal Foster, 145–154. Toronto: Bay
Press.
Cran, Rona. 2014. Collage in
Twentieth-Century Art, Literature and Culture: Joseph Cornell,
William Burroughs, Frank O’Hara and Bob Dylan, 224 & 136.
Oxford & New York: Ashgate.
Markson, David. 1996. Reader’s Block.
Dalkey Archive.
Markson, David. 2004. Vanishing Point.
Shoemaker & Hoard.
Markson, David. 2007. The Last Novel.
Counterpoint.
Markson, David. 2010. This is Not a Novel.
CB Editions.
Olson, Lance and Andi. 2000. Sewing Shut My
Eyes. Black Ice Books.
Olson, Lance. 2009. Head in Flames.
Chiasmus.
Olson, Lance. 2017. Dreamlives of Debris.
Dzanc.
Raaberg, Gwen. 1998. ‘Beyond Fragmentation: Collage as Feminist
Strategy in the Arts’. Mosaic 31(3): 153.
https://www.jstor.org/stable/44029815?seq=1
(accessed 2 Feb. 2020).
________________________________________________________
NOTES
C21 Literature: Journal
of 21st-century Writings is the journal of
the British Association for Contemporary Literary Studies (BACLS).
It is an open-accss
publication, made freely available under licence. The book
review can be
read online:
https://c21.openlibhums.org/article/id/1989
________________________________________________________