Showing posts with label Film Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Film Reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, June 30, 2018

FILM REVIEW: All the President's Men (1976)

 
  Dustin Hofman and Robert Redford as Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward 
in All the President's Men 
 

APRIL 7th, 2026 is the 50th anniversary of, arguably, one of the most well-known, most lauded and most discussed movie in cinematic history. Starring Robert Redford (1936 - 2025) and Dustin Hoffman (b.1937) as Bob Woodward1 and Carl Bernstein2 respectively, All the President's Men (1976) is based on the journalists' book of the same name, originally published in June 1974. The screenplay, written by William Goldman (1931 - 2008)3 is directed by Alan J. Pakula (1928 – 1998)4. David Smith, The Guardian's bureau chief in Washington, DC, talks of Pakula's 'flawless' direction, writing that:-

the movie was a box-office hit, nominated for eight Oscars and winning four, including best adapted screenplay for William Goldman and best supporting actor for Jason Robards as the Post's editor, Ben Bradlee

Telling the real-life story of the so-called Watergate Scandal which occurred during President Richard Nixon's 1972 re-election campaign, the movie's premise focuses on the role played by the two Washington Post journalists, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, in uncovering the plot to foil the election campaign in the President's favour by breaking into the headquarters of the Democratic National Committee and planting listening devices. Initially assumed to be a relatively minor incident, the two young journalists, hungry for a meaty story, begin their own investigations which lead them into a labyrinth of secrecy and deceit. They eventually discover that members of President Nixon’s re-election campaign were responsible for instigating the break-in. Nixon's efforts to conceal his administration's involvement in the conspiracy ultimately led to an impeachment process and his resignation in August 1974.

The movie begins with archive footage of Nixon's night-time arrival by helicopter in Washington, DC for his speech to the House of Congress. Meanwhile, a security guard, on his rounds, finds masking tape on the catch of the door to the Committee's office to prevent it locking and contacts the police. Believing this potentially to be the big break they're looking for, we see Woodward and Bernstein the next day attempting to persuade their boss, the Washington Post's managing editor Ben Bradlee5, to allow them to take on the story instead of giving it to another, more long-serving, reporter.

The film follows the young journalists' journey to the publication of the series pf articles they write as their digging exposes more and more irregularities. It depicts the painstaking nature of source verification and the ethical dilemmas faced by those in pursuit of the truth. With each new revelation the tension increases as the various threads of corruption begin to unravel.

Woodward phones all the people and organisations he deems might know something about the members of the White House who could have been behind arranging the break-in. But, his efforts are in vain. Everyone he speaks to denies knowing the men even though Woodward has information that says otherwise. In desperation, he calls a contact from a public call box who has helped him out before. Known merely as 'Deep Throat'6 the man says at first that this time is different and he is unable to help the young journalist, but then he relents and they meet in an eerie underground car park, Deep Throat refuses to supply information outright, asking instead that Woodward tells him what he knows and he will either confirm or deny what the jounalist says.

When all their attempts to confirm those they suspect to be either behind or involved in the break-in fail, Woodward and Bernstein, both together and seperately, go knocking on the door of secretaries and administration staff who worked for members of the Democratic National Committee7. Yet despite the numerous cups of coffee accepted and drunk during these visits their endevours yield less than satisfactory results. Eventually they think they have the confirmation they need to write an accurate article and spend all night writing it, but when it's finally published the accused parties begin a new wave of denials, with some threatening law suits.

The thread running through the movie is the constant fear that must be the norm in any newspaper office. The fear that carelessness, inadequate proof and lack of sufficiently thorough fact-checking creates slip-ups and accidental inaccuracies which may, if serious enough, potentially result in court cases. The acting and scene-setting throughout All the President’s Men is excellent, of course, the latter portraying the frenetic atmosphere of a newsroom and the fact that the making of news is a 24/7 event. News doesn't stop happening at 5.00pm each day before resuming at 8.00am the following morning.

The movie has a surprisingly abrupt ending. We see Woodward and Bernstein typing up their final article. while their colleagues are gathered around the television watching Richard Nixon7 being re-elected as President of the United States on 7 November 1972. Nixon defeated his Democrat rival, George McGovern8 in a landslide victory, winning 60.7% of the popular vote and carrying 49 out of 50 states. The last shot of he movie is of their article being typeset for publication the next day. Then the screen goes black and a list of the cast and production crew appears.

All the President’s Men endures due to the historical importance of its subject matter and the way it celebrates the values of diligence, skepticism, and moral courage. Alan J. Pakula’s direction, paired with taut writing and distinctive performances, delivers a film that is gripping in its detail and lasting in its impact.

______________________________________________________

REFERENCES

1 BOB WOODWARD (b.1943), American investigative journalist and author. Worked at the Washington Post from 1971 to 1977. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Woodward

2 CARL BERNSTEIN (b.1944), American investigative journalist and author. Worked at the Washington Post from 1966 to 1977. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Bernstein

3 William Goldman also wrote the screenplay for Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) and those based on two of his own novels, Marathon Man (1974) and The Princess Bride (1973)

4 Alan Pakula's other notable films included Comes a Horseman (1978), Starting Over (1979), Sophie's Choice (1982), Presumed Innocent (1990), and The Pelican Brief (1993). He also produced the movie To Kill a Mockingbird (1962).

5 Ben Bradlee (1921 – 2014), managing and, later, executive editor of The Washington Post. Known also for the publication of the Pentagon Papers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Bradlee

6 Mark Felt (1913 – 2008), the real 'Deep Throat'. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Felt

7 Richard Nixon (1913 – 1994), 37th president of the United States. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Nixon

8 George McGovern (1922 – 2012), American politician, diplomat, and historian from South Dakota https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_McGovern

 

* * * * * * * 


ALL THE PRESIDENT'S MEN, 1976 (film)
https://archive.org/details/all-the-presidents-men-1976_202406

 
DOCUMENTARY Watergate: All the president's men revisited Nixon (1976)                                    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_bIFjDMs_I

MOVIE Mark Felt: The Man Who Brought Down the White House (2017)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_DvQIdrhHM

WASHINGTON POST https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Washington_Post

08/04/2026  

_______________________________________________________

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

An Inconvenient Truth

I ATTENDED the free showing at the local cinema of Al Gore's Oscar-winning documentary An inconvenient truth with a slight sense of trepidation. All the reviews I had read before going felt the film was difficult to watch and that as a documentary it was rather too long.

The movie was being shown in conjunction with the signing of the Scottish Declaration on Climate Change by the Chief Executive of the local council. It was to promote awareness within the island community where I live, of the need to look after our environment and to encourage healthy debate about how everyone, from individuals to schools and businesses can play an important part. The Islands are already at the global forefront of technology in the field of renewable energy, researching and testing the world's first wave making machine over the past two and a half years. The Polamis is now installed and working a few miles off-shore. The fact that the recent proposal to establish a wind farm also, was met with major opposition for fear that it would spoil the view over the wealth of neolithic and bronze-age monuments this area is blessed with, is surprising therefore, and a story for another time.

Personally I found An inconvenient truth much easier to digest than expected. Whatever one might think about Al Gore as a person or as a politician, there can be no doubt that he is passionate about his subject which helps to make it more palatable to his audience than it would otherwise have been. The documentary follows Gore on his lecture tours and features him facing halls filled, by turns, with bemused/interested-looking students, using excellent, computer-generated graphics to illustrate his points, I can see, though, that some will find this method of presentation too dry to hold their attention. For me it worked very well. Probably better than if he had been followed around the countryside and across continents by a camera crew and a couple of producers.

To break the monotony of being holed up inside a lecture theatre Gore takes time out to reflect on a few episodes in his personal life which significantly affected him. The first, every parent's nightmare, tells of how his young son escaped from his father's grip while crossing a busy street and being hit by an oncoming car. Although touching in its own right it is clearly only an attempt to show that Gore has warmth and compassion, irrespective of how he comes across in his career. The episode, however, has little to do with concern for our planet, as far as I can see. His own backstory of how he grew up on a tobacco farm and his beloved sister dying of lung cancer at the age of forty five are more relevant to the theme and may make a greater impact on his audience.

Other interludes from Gore's lectures show him being visibly touched by the obvious effects of global warming he observes, first flying over Antarctica and later over a parched landscape with black smoke belching out from huge chimney stacks in the background.

The film ends with the ex-politician impelling us to tell everyone to change their ways, our parents, our spouses, our children, to enable us to endow future generations with a life on this planet such as we are enjoying ourselves. This final attempt to drive the message home seemed to me unnecessary and to be over-egging the pudding somewhat. However, there can be no doubt that this is an important movie, totally relevant to our time and our changing world. Whether it is warning enough to convince the many cynics out there who remain dubious that climate change is happening to the threatening degree that it is claimed, remains to be seen.

17/04/07

Monday, March 19, 2007

FILM REVIEW: Smilla’s Sense of Snow (1997)

Billie August (director) & Ann Biderman (screenplay)

A SIX year old Inuit boy falls to his death from the roof of a multi-storey apartment block in Copenhagen. What had caused this youngster, who feared heights, to go there at all? Smilla, a scientist and the lad’s neighbour knows instinctively that it can’t just have been an accident.

Herself part Inuit, having grown up in Greenland, Smilla has seen snow in all its forms and knows that the tracks running in a straight line to the edge of the roof are not those of a boy at play as those around her maintain. She suspects something far more sinister to be the cause of death.

Julia Ormond, as Smilla, leads the strong cast featuring Gabriel Byrne, Richard Harris, Jim Broadbent, Robert Loggia and Vanessa Redgrave. Smilla’s frustration with her life constantly bubbles, barely suppressed, beneath the surface and in a strange way serves to emphasize her beauty. She was brought to Denmark by her father following her mother’s death and deeply resents him for that. "Iam tired of wondering why every day I am on this earth I'm an exile.", she tells her father towards the end of the movie. Smilla buries herself in her work as a kind of escape.

Flashbacks provide the backstory of how Smilla befriends her young neighbour, Isaiah, when he shyly appears at her door wanting to be read to. Initially she refuses to let him in wishing to maintain her self-imposed isolation from the world around her, but later she relents, even giving him a bath. Through a letter his mother gives her she is able to establish that a mysterious link exists between the boy’s death and the Greenland Mining Company. Isaiah’s post mortem reveals some disturbing marks on his body. Eventually, via several complex paths of investigation, Smilla discovers that the boy had apparently been victim to a ruthless secret medical experiment conducted by the head of the company (Richard Harris).

In the film at least, Smilla’s other neighbour (Gabriel Byrne) serves only really to add an air of mystery. An out-of-work mechanic he might almost appear to be stalking Smilla, though he claims he loved Isaiah too and wants to establish how the lad met his death. He provides a potential love interest for Smilla and although she does seek solace in his arms after he helps her with a particularly tricky part of her investigations, the film leaves it open to the viewer as to whether or not their relationship ever develops into anything more than friendship.

The stunningly bright scenery of Greenland at the start of this psychological drama is not carried through to the rest of the movie. Copenhagen isn’t portrayed as the elegant, vibrant city it is, but as the dreary grey place the unhappy Smilla sees it as. Most of the story is totally gripping, involving the viewer in Smilla’s quest to find out how Isaiah died and thereby perhaps gaining a sense of closure herself. However, sadly, the last half hour or so of the film fails to deliver on its promising beginning. The ending is weak, confused and seems to have difficulty in finding a satisfactory conclusion. That said, Smilla’s Sense of Snow is an unusual and bewitching story, very different from today’s more predictable, sometimes even quite formulaic plotlines. By this virtue alone, it is a movie well worth seeing.

19/03/07

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

FILM REVIEW: Message in the Bottle (1999)

Luis Mandoki (director) & Gerald DiPego (screenplay)

IT is not often that a movie works better than the book it is based on, but Message in a Bottle is a case in point.

I happened to catch the end of this film when it was shown on television a few Christmases ago. It struck me then that I had probably missed a very special movie. It’s only recently, though, that I got around to obtaining it on DVD. I confess I’ve watched it several times now. The film lingers on my mind long after the credits have rolled and moves me more than I can say. The ending is so unexpected, it never fails to shock.

The story of a love found and lost is told with far greater poignancy and effect on screen than it is in Nicolas Sparks’ novel of the same name. The book, in my view, is too drawn out and dilutes the impact of the plotline. I have always considered Kevin Costner an actor of real quality and talent. One can count on the films in which he chooses to star as being superior to so many more mediocre ones hitting cinema screens today. Here he is perfectly cast as the soft-spoken grieving widower, Garret Blake, still desperately pining over the loss of his wife two years earlier. Theresa Osborne, played with a wonderful sense of vulnerability by Robin Wright Penn, is researcher/columnist at the Chicago Tribune. Her life changes forever the day she finds the message in a bottle whilst jogging along a beach on Cape Cod. The beautiful message addressed to ‘Catherine’ moves her deeply and she sets out to discover more about its author.

Theresa’s research leads her to St. Clare, a small town in North Carolina, where Garret (author of the message) has a boat building and restoration business. Both have been scarred by love before – Garret still lives with Catherine’s shadow whilst Theresa is recovering from a painful divorce. They struggle with conversation, finding an attraction they cannot deny, but are uncertain of themselves and uncertain of how to discover each other. The inner torment both characters feel is almost tangible. Neither is sure they can be open to a new relationship, nor are they ready to say goodbye to something that is starting to feel so right.

Paul Newman almost steals the show as Garret’s cantankerous, but endearing father who is probably dealing with demons of his own.

The gorgeous scenery in which this movie is set, together with the dreamy quality of how some of the scenes are shot only add to its beauty and ensures its timelessness in the archives of romantic drama films.

21/02/07

Sunday, January 14, 2007

FILM REVIEW: Defence of the Realm (1985)

David Drury (director) & Martin Stellman (screenplay)

THIS is one of two of my favourite British films of the 1980s. One can only imagine what it must be like, as a seasoned hack following a story, to have one’s flat broken into and ransacked by those making the story, trying to eradicate any evidence of their guilt obtained by said hack though digging and research.

The film, made in a politically charged Britain when there was already a plethora of similar plots on our screens in the form of (amongst others) the TV serialisations of John Le Carré’s Smiley’s People and Tinker, Taylor, Soldier, Spy, was confirmation that the cold war was still very much in evidence, both in real and fictional terms. If a writer was short of a good plot he could always conjure up a cold war story to guarantee a keen audience. It would still be a while before the public would tire of the genre. A stellar cast further ensured the film’s appeal.

A prominent government official (Ian Bannen) involved in a sex scandal is suspected to be linked to a KGB agent. Gabriel Byrne in his first starring role plays Nick Mullen, a young reporter looking for the big story to get his career off the ground. He receives a tip-off that the MP’s misdemeanours are really a government cover-up for something much more serious. He has merely been made a scapegoat to distract from what is really going on. Despite warnings from his mentor and tired hack Vernon Bayliss (Denholm Elliot) Mullen charges in to get to the bottom of the story. Eventually Bayliss relents and teams up with Mullen and Nina Beckman (Greta Scacchi), the MP’s assistant, to discover the truth. In the course of their search they seriously endanger their lives. While Mullen and Beckman narrowly escape what could be grave consequences to their ‘digging’, Bayliss is found dead in his apartment after meeting with a government mole. It is also his flat which is searched during the team’s investigations.

Also starring as the reporters’ colleague at the newspaper office is Bill Patterson. Fulton Mackay plays the paper’s chief editor.

Defence of the Realm is thoughtfully shot to create atmosphere as well as showing the director’s obvious desire to preserve a sense of the time and history in which the film is set -- when newspaper offices were still cramped and seedy places and the typewriter and spiral notebook were a journalist’s tools of the trade. Some might feel the ending is a little unsatisfactory, but the film’s enduring quality nevertheless shines through brightly enough.

14/01/07

Thursday, August 10, 2006

FILM REVIEW: The Lake House (2006)

Alejandro Agresti (director) David Auburn (screenplay)

A BEAUTIFUL house situated perfectly on a idyllic lake in the Illinois countryside. Two people living there at different times two years apart strike up an unlikely friendship by correspondence. The movie has been variously described as beautiful, moving, a fantasy, a romantic comedy. There can be absolutely no doubt that it is beautifully filmed, but personally I found the concept of the two main characters living in different years and still able to communicate as though in the present oddly disturbing and unsatisfying. It seemed totally uncessary to be dragged between the two different periods against my will. I felt always somehow to be lagging behind what was actually happening, never quite able to catch up, never quite managing to make sense of it all.

The story is based on a South Korean film called Il Mare. As in almost all the roles she takes on Sandra Bullock plays, what I have come to call, her desperate and lonely female part. She is partnered for the first time since Speed (1994) with Keanu Reeves.

In 2004 Alex moves into the Lake House in rural Illinois originally designed by his architect father (Christopher Plummer) after Kate, a doctor, vacates it in 2006 to take up a hospital post in Chicago. She leaves a note for the new tenant asking him to kindly forward her mail. Alex hadn’t expected anyone to have been living in the house and with his curiosity aroused replies to Kate’s note. He also befriends the same dog which Kate had when she lived in the house two years earlier. Alex personally takes her mail to the address she gives him in Chicago. He finds himself standing in front of a building which is still under construction. It is then he realises their bizarre situation - they live in different times. It is all a bit twilight zone(ish).

Alex and Kate start to write, leaving letters for each other in the mailbox at the house. During the course of their correspondence it becomes clear that they are gradually falling in love even though they have never met. They are intrigued by the connection they feel and try to arrange to meet up, but unsurprisingly that doesn’t quite work out as they might have hoped. There are a couple more twists and turns in the plot, but these hardly add any real value or make the tale any more three dimentional.

I must admit I would comprehend the story better if the two periods were reversed, although the conclusion, when events come full circle, does at least leave the viewer with more of a sense of completeness than might have been expected half way through, As one review noted, it is ultimately a work of unfulfilled potential.

10/08/06

Tuesday, March 23, 2004

FILM REVIEW: Two Weeks Notice (2003)

Release date: 7 February 2003

THERE had been a fair amount of hype about the movie Two Weeks Notice prior to its release date in February 2003, but I never got a chance to see it on the big screen. In early December I found myself with a spare evening and decided to rent it on video.

Written by Sandra Bullock of Speed, The Net and While You were Sleeping fame she stars herself, together with Hugh Grant.

I ask myself whether Bullock ever plays anything other than a lonely, but feisty single female living on her own, ordering take-outs for one every night. I guess Hugh Grant mostly plays similar roles too, as the scatter brained, slightly awkward and easily embarrassed love god who makes sure the female lead gets to have the required fairy tale ending. I'm thinking here of Four Weddings and a Funeral, Notting Hill, Bridget Jones's Diary and lately Love Actually.

Bullock takes on the role of tree hugging lawyer who single handedly attempts to save her local neighbourhood from destruction. She agrees to work for George Wade (Hugh Grant) an influential property lawyer and, as is to be expected, at first they don’t really get on, throwing insults at each other as Bullock bumbles her way through the film with feeble lines and regularly falling over things as though she had perfected it as an art form. All this makes it rather difficult to believe that she is supposed to portray a brilliant professional. Although there has been some comedy up to this point, almost slapstick in places, little romance has been in evidence.

Bullock becomes fed up with her demanding boss and attempts to leave her job, but by now Grant realises how much he has come to depend on his head strong colleague and doesn’t let her go. She even has to help him decide which suit and tie to wear to an important function.

True to every romantic comedy, the sparks continue to fly amidst the growing attraction between the two lawyers and of course the film ends with them finding true love. The audience, however, is left slightly wanting, since the script and the acting never really come close to fulfilling the expectations of a satisfying on screen experience of this genre.

23/03/04

Monday, March 22, 2004

FILM REVIEW: LOTR .... Return of the King

THE Pickaquoy Centre, Orkney’s very own leisure centre, is five years old this month. To celebrate this milestone a series of special events are being held over the next few weeks. Amongst them is a mini film festival showing the five most popular films during this period. They include Notting Hill, Bridget Jones’ Diary and The Perfect Storm. This last weekend there were free showings of the final film in Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings Trilogy. Naturally I just had to take the opportunity to go along and see what all the fuss has been about.

‘Spectacular’, if just one word was needed to describe The Return of the King. I am sure the previous two films are equally impressive to have amassed as many accolades as they have. I may not be J.J.R. Tolkien’s keenest fan, having struggled terribly with at least two of his books during my teens, but I am still able to appreciate the dedication that has gone into making these films. As far as I can tell, at least, the film is pretty close to the book. Perhaps most amazingly to me is the fact that the settings are uncannily close to what my imagination had conjured up for me when I read the story. So either Tolkien’s descriptions are that vivid or Peter Jackson’s imagination works along similar lines to my own. He must, of course, be Tolkien’s No.1 fan of all time to have devoted eight years of his life realising this magnificent cinematic feat.

As the book is too, the storyline is complex, many layers deep and multi-faceted. Jackson cleverly uses all methods of cinematography to bring it to life perfectly. Beautiful scenery to use as the ideal backdrop, glorious sets, inspired use of computer technology to generate characters and battle scenes and a fantastic cast of actors, all playing their best to make an awesome whole, no one out shining anyone else. There are many outstanding performances here, not only that of Ian McKellern as Gandalf, which has deservedly been recognised. The Hobbits are all excellently portrayed and as someone in a review somewhere else has already said, Sean Astin playing Sam Wiseman, Frodo’s gardener and best friend should rightfully have been awarded an Oscar for best supporting role.

A superb blend of tension, suspense, several emotionally moving moments (notably Frodo taking his farewell from the Hobbits) and even the occasional spot of humour makes this three hour long epic seem only half its length even to the most uninitiated exponent of this genre. Howard Shore’s exemplary musical score giving colour and mood to the whole viewing experience is just one more aspect which deserves to be mentioned. This film and the LOTR Trilogy as a whole must go down in cinematic history as the greatest achievement to date in every facet of its accomplishment. May it continue to astound, fascinate and entertain audiences the world for many generations to come. It will be named as a classic of its time in the same breath as movies like Ivanhoe, Casablanca, Citizen Kane, Jaws, and Jurassic Park.

22/03/04

Friday, November 14, 2003

FILM REVIEW: Maurice (1987)

MAURICE, the 1987 Merchant Ivory film was shown on television late one night last weekend. A difficult subject sensitively handled. It moved me .... perhaps even more than when I saw it on its initial release in the cinema.

Beautifully realised and well acted throughout, it deals with the coming of age of a couple of young British university students during the first decade of the 20th Century. Brilliantly played by Hugh Grant as Clive Durham and James Wilby as Maurice Hall, the two young men discover their homosexuality through each other and try to come to terms with it. One can easily imagine the emotional rollercoaster anyone going on this journey will experience, but during the era in question such a trauma will have been even more difficult than it would be today. Attitudes were already beginning to change about certain social issues and were really quite liberal for the day, but homosexuality was certainly not one of them. It was to remain a subject very much taboo for at least another sixty years, even though homosexuality was indisputably rife in schools, colleges and universities throughout the land.

The liaison of Clive and Maurice comes to the attention of the headmaster and Maurice is expelled. He goes home to his dysfunctional family where his father, played by Denholm Elliott tells him he is probably more cut out for a job in the city anyway.

Meanwhile Clive finishes university and gives in to the pressures of society by marrying the beautiful Anne, played by Phoebe Nicholls. Maurice is a frequent guest at their house. He is unable to understand Clive’s desire to suppress his true sexual leaning. He turns to hypnosis to cure his own unspeakable longings. It proves to be unsuccessful though, especially once he meets Clive's broodingly sullen, rough and ready gamekeeper, Alec Scudder, marvellously played by Rupert Graves. Although living in very different social spheres both men question the rules of their society which try so hard to keep them apart. Maurice eventually realises he is prepared to risk public censure and disgrace in order to hold onto his chance of love.

Much has changed, even since the 1980s. This is an unashamedly gay love story and although sensitively and tenderly portrayed, the film will initially undoubtedly have raised renewed questions about how much social attitudes had actually changed since the beginning of that century.

14/11/03

About

  2026 is National Year of Reading      Carola Huttmann I AM a housebound writer, book reviewer, lived experience advocate and independent...