Showing posts with label Autobiography. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Autobiography. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

BOOK REVIEW: For the Islands I Sing, by George Mackay Brown

AFTER reading Maggie Fergusson’s superb biography of George Mackay Brown I couldn’t wait to reread the writer and poet’s own autobiography. I bought the book as soon as it was published, twelve years ago and although I set about reading it immediately I did so during a job which I hated. The book became a kind of diversion technique and I remembered less about its contents than about the tedious work I was doing. In the intervening years I have seen reviews which described it variously as 'disingenuous', ‘disappointing’, ‘selective’, ‘slight’. Hence, I thought, it was high time to revisit it, paying it the attention it deserved. And what a joy it was too. I certainly felt those negative comments of reviewers misplaced, or maybe, they had simply taken the term 'autobiography' too literally. The book is not so much a chronicle of the poet's life as a series of stream-of-consciousness musings about significant episodes in his life and the people within it who played an important role . His style is endearing, intimate almost, as though, during a cosy winter evening by the fire he is alone with the reader sharing with him his reminiscences. His humour makes the work sparkle.

Around the time I was establishing myself as a freelance writer I penned my own review of the autobiography for my portfolio. I wondered if my initial impressions would be different after reading it again, but I am pleased to say I still believe that it is an acurate portrayal.

George Mackay Brown, the Orcadian poet and story writer, wrote his autobiography 'For the Islands I Sing' in the years before his death in April 1996, but he did not want it to be published during his lifetime. It is a beautifully touching and honest account of a life that began rather insignificantly, but ended with him having become one of the most acclaimed writers of the second half of the twentieth Century.

Anyone looking here for self analysis of his work will be disappointed. Instead, GBM, as he was known to most, chooses to reminisce about his life, his family and friends, occasionally giving the reader a bird's eye view of other aspects of Orkney life also.

Brown was born in Stromness, Orkney's second town, and after illustrating what life there was like during his early years, he provides a brilliant insight into his background, making his phenomenal worldwide success perhaps all the more surprising. He was the last of seven children, born into a 'poor family'.

Brown's early life was dogged by recurring bouts of tuberculosis, but things eventually took an upward turn when he met the Orkney-born poet Edwin Muir who invited him to study at Newbattle Abbey in Dalkeith where Muir was warden. Later GMB was to admit that it was this time at Newbattle that gave him the inspiration and direction he so badly sought.

Most of his work is mentioned merely in passing, perhaps reflecting the quiet, self effacing man he was. Rather George Mackay Brown prefers to tell about the people who made an impression on his life. Apart from an appendix which he added in 1993 he wrote the main part of his autobiography in 1985, eleven years before his death.

© Carola Huttmann, February 2003

REF. For the Islands I Sing, by George Mackay Brown
Publisher: John Murray (24 April 1997), 192 pages, hb


01/07/09

Sunday, July 23, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: On Writing, by Stephen King

I AM not a huge fan of the horror genre - in fact, if truth be known, I positively fear it. So, it was entirely by accident that I came to discover what a superb wordsmith Stephen King is. I read a recommendation of his book On Writing on an online journalists forum which mildly aroused my curiosity about this author. Until that time I had read non of his novels although I did see the films Carrie and The Shawshank Redemption when they first hit the cinemas. I found On Writing in the library one day, a couple of months ago when I was looking for a different book entirely. I quickly came to admire and respect Stephen King as a writer and as a person. His turn of phrase appeals to me and he clearly loves words. The ability to use them well as though they were second nature to him is impressive and I admit to experiencing a slight pang of guilt that for too long I had presumed Stephen King to be a writer of multi-million airport trash - read once and then discarded.

The first part of On Writing is autobiographical (or his writing memoirs, as he refers to it). The second part is some astonishingly sound advice on writing fiction. My only criticism is that the book could have done with better editing, but that aspect aside it is, in my view, a work well worth recommending to any new or even established novelist.
I am reading at the moment my first Stephen King novel which, in my opinion, is more a thriller than a horror story. The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon is the tale of Tricia McFarland who becomes lost in the woods off the Appalachian Trail in Maine.
Possibly I don’t have the stomach to read some of King’s other books, those with rather more chilling themes, but I am keen to explore the way he writes his short stories. I will simply have to grit my teeth to get through the scariest ones. By definition the writing here has to be tighter and more controlled than in a novel. The shock impact, therefore, may be greater, since there is less space to create atmosphere, anticipation and build-up to any particularly vile imagery or event in the story. I expect some real revelations how, through the clever use of words, description, dialogue and sentence structure King manages to establish blood-curling tension, anticipation and surprise in a short time.
The introduction to his volume of collected short stories Night Shift (also the title of one of the tales therein) is written by John D. MacDonald, best known for a series of American detectives stories. He believed that even against his superior age and writing experience his writing at forty was never as good as King’s at thirty and King’s writing at forty was better than MacDonald’s own would ever be. That is an admission of some magnitude, I would suggest. MacDonald died nine years after Night Shift was first published.

23/07/06

About

  2026 is National Year of Reading      Carola Huttmann I AM a housebound writer, book reviewer, lived experience advocate and independent...