Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts

Saturday, June 30, 2018

Book Reviews (2026)

 2026 is the National Year of Reading, so I'd encourage everyone to make it their mission to read more. Make it your habit to always carry a book. whether you're standing in line somewhere, waiting at a bus stop or feeling a little bored on a wet Sunday afternoon, unsure what to do with yourself. Those are the ideal moments to pick up book and immerse yourself in another world, meet different characters, discover new authors or unfamiliar cultures. If fiction isn't your thing, consider the topics you've always wanted to know more about, but never had the time or felt the motivation to find a book that could help you learn more. Make the National Year of Reading 2026 also the year of acquiring new knowledge and broadening your understanding of the world.

For reviews from previous years, please click here: 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025. 

Partita, by Barbara Kingsolver

John of John, by Douglas Stuart

Gaining Ground, by Joan Barfoot 

Everything to the Sea, by Alice Upano

Contrapposto, by Dave Eggers

The Eights, by Joanna Miller

The Rush, by Beth Lewis 

Wildly Different, by Sarah Lonsdale

This Bright Life, by Karen Campbell

The Artful Anna Harris, by Tracy Maton

Plato: A Civic Life, by Carol Atack

Blank Canvas, by Grace Murray  

  

BOOK REVIEW: Michel Foucault, the State and the Social Sciences, by Arnault Skornicki (Author), Andrew Brown (tr.)

 IN this academic monograph the author argues that Foucault should be regarded as providing, not a facile theory of the state as power, but a complex discussion on a multitude of social networks working together to investigate the state as an institution. He shows that Foucault saw political domination as not the result of the monopolization of power, as in Max Weber’s theory of the state, but as the result of a layering and stratification of different discourses and networks of power within society.

Skornicki assesses how Foucault's approach to both sociology and genealogy differs from that of earlier sociologists and philosophers, such as Immanuel Kant (1724 – 1804) or Max Weber (1864 – 1920) with Weber's interpretation leaning towards Marxism while Foucault is influenced by Nietzschean thinking (Skornicki, 2025 : 15).

He goes on to define Foucault's definition of 'state', taking the reader back in history to how earlier figures determined its meaning and concept (Skornicki, 2025 : 23):

  • The English philosopher Thomas Hobbes (1588 –1679) regarded sovereignty as a social contract between a government and its people.

  • The French juror and political philosopher, Jean Bodin (1530 – 1596) stated that sovereignty must be 'absolute, perpetual, and indivisible', meaning that ultimate authority resides in a single ruler, a group, or the entire body of citizens.

  • Charles Loyseau (1564 - 1627), an eminent jurist under Louis XIII, allegedly identified sovereignty as being an authoritarian state which ruled its citizens by setting rigorous boundaries that allowed only limited social mobility. These he set out in his text of 1610, known as A Treatise on Orders.

Foucault's own view is that sovereignty is ‘an ideology' and that 'a country's laws are the deliberately mystifying language of state power employed to organise and control its population' (Skornicki, 2025 : 23).

There is a lot of repetition, most notably on the two topics which, arguably, were Foucault's most profound preoccupation: the concepts of knowledge and power in all their different guises. An additional subtext being the notion of sovereignty and the controlling powers government states exert over their citizens. These concerns take up the largest proportion of the book, with separate sections or chapters reiterating certain arguments and ideas time and again.

In terms of his theories about knowledge and power in their broadest definition, Foucault again, appears to submit to Nietzschean ideas. Thus, he sees power not as a substance or a thing one holds, but a relationship. According to Skornicki Foucault believes that power is not located in specific institutions, but comes from everywhere because it can be found everywhere, extending through all areas of society. The author writes (Skornicki, 2025 : 26):

Power unfolds in a differential force field. It is not specifically violence, constraint (like a force that breaks something or bends a body), nor consent: what distinguishes it from repression and ideology is that it does not bear within itself either threat or agreement (although it very often needs both), but manifests itself as cunning, incitement, facilitation, contrariety, calculation, anticipation or insinuation.

Skornicki appears to be unsure of Foucault's true position on Marxism, citing scholars holding opposing views. He also seems uncertain about whether or not Foucault supported Marx's capitalist, authoritarian ideology. Perhaps unwilling to bear the responsibility of committing himself to either side of the debate, the author, simply lays out the alternative viewpoints without further comment (Skornicki, 2025 : 64):

Étienne Balibar and Roberto Nigro believe that Foucault systematically sought to build an alternative approach to that of Marx, one which does not exclude crossovers, ‘points of heresy’ (Balibar) and parallels between their respective genealogies of capitalism: difference is far from being inevitably contradiction (Balibar, 1997: 281–319; 2004; Nigro, 2011). On the other hand, neo-Althusserian philosophers, such as Stéphane Legrand and G. Sibertin-Blanc, and even the German sociologist Thomas Lemke, argue for the compatibility of Marx and Foucault, and even for the existence of an authentic Marxism in Foucault and his enlistment into anti-capitalist struggle, against the liberal or boss-friendly ‘recuperations’ of which he was a victim.

In a further move to distance himself from the argument, Skornicki recommends that 'informed readers' of the works of Max Weber (1864 – 1920) and Norbert Elias (1897 – 1990) should make up their own minds, reasoning that the two sociologists each interpreted Marxism in their own way. Both men, Skornicki believes, viewed capital accumulation as being equal to the means by which political domination is achieved.

Skornicki moves on to discuss the interpretation and practical implementation of man-made time that accompanied the start of the Industrial Revolution (as opposed to time dictated by nature and the rhythm of the seasons). He explores how the clock controls workers' tasks on factory production lines. he suggests that Foucault's theory, expressed in his Manifesto Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (1975), seeks what he calls a 'middle ground' between the perspectives of Marx and the Irish philosopher and social reformer, William Thompson (1775 – 1833) who centered their ideas and practices only on how the world of work could be regulated to ensure employers had the means of controlling employees and to exert punishments if tasks were not performed to a manager's satisfaction. The practices he recommends are based on how penal reform and punishment was enforced in French prisons at the time. Foucault, Skornicki opines, wanted time-management to apply universally to 'most institutions through which individuals pass: schools, hospitals, families, barracks, prisons, and so on' (Skornicki, 2025 : 71). In one of his lectures delivered to students at the Collège de France in Paris, between 1972 and 1973, collated and published in an English translation by Graham Burchell, under the title, The Punitive Society, in 2015, Foucault expounded his ideas thus (Foucault, 2015 : 71):

Disciplinary society is distinguished by the control over time that we find in prisons as well as in factories: ‘the prison-form and the wage-form are historically twin forms, without us being able to say yet what their exact relationships are.

Instead of addressing one of Foucault's preoccupations at a time in its entirety, Skornicki employs a somewhat scattergun approach to writing, frequently returning to topics previously discussed without anything obvious linking them to the new issue he is examining. One topic he goes back to several times is that of sovereignty and statehood. It is unclear why Skornicki chooses to leave Foucault’s analyses of the so-called 'Westphalian System’ — the principle held in international law that each state has exclusive sovereignty over its territory — and his discourse on the balance of powers within the European political context of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries to near the the end of the book. The narrative would surely have been better served by fully developing Foucault's argument that power is part of state control earlier in the text when the author first puts the matter of sovereignty under the microscope.

Skornicki outlines somewhat more briefly the theories behind the concept of Territorialization in relation to both geographical environments and populations, showing how its control at once limits and liberates individuals, allowing them to move about freely, trade with one another within certain criteria and, returning once again to the construct of control and sovereignty, he explores the concept of biopolitics, that is how governmental power operates through the management and regulation of a population's lives and institutions.

One of the longest sections of the book is the exploration of historic shifts in religious attitudes and practices. Skornicki takes the reader back to the Middle Ages and the notion that Man is a sheep under the care of pastoral powers which, in their various guises, act as shepherds. He then moves forward to the theologian John Wesley (1703 - 1791), founder of the Methodist Movement, and the use of Calvinist influences to discipline citizens. Of Wesley, the author writes (Skornicki, 2025 : 112):

His charitable actions for the benefit of the poor were combined with an exhortation to moral rigour, an extreme religious rigour among his followers, an aversion to disorder and revolutions and a respect for the established authorities, and a continual effort to moralize the working classes, which involved the fight against alcoholism, debauchery, and the vain entertainments of the cabaret and the theatre.

While the Methodist Movement grew, the Quaker Movement, established around a century earlier under the English religious dissenter, George Fox (1624 - 1691) became considerably weaker after it expanded across the Atlantic to the Americas. Explaining Foucault's own stance on the purpose of religion, the author notes (Skornicki, 2025 : 112):

Foucault long considered the Christian religion as a governmentality that was to an extreme degree a matter of ‘pure obedience’: a type of conduct valued for its own sake, characterized by the renunciation of one’s own will, surrendering oneself wholly to the will of God, that is, of his pastors.

In his lectures and the articles he wrote, Foucault repeatedly extolled the opinion that 'the specificity of power in the West is due to the influence of the Christian Church'.

The slightly discombobulating structure of the book in which Skornicki skips back and forth between the topics he covers notwithstanding, this study of Michel Foucault's position on the politics of power exertion on states and the societies they control, is nevertheless an erudite yet accessible discourse which both practising Foucault scholars and those merely curious about his theories will find valuable reading. Andrew Brown's translation is extremely competent on the whole, but does, at times, come across as rather galumphing and awkward in a way that has nothing to do with it being an academic text and everything to do with the difficulties of articulating linguistic nuances when translating from a Romance to a Germanic language.


BOOK
Michel Foucault, the State and the Social Sciences, by Arnault Skornicki (Author), Andrew Brown (tr.)
Hardcover: 232 pages
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan (02 Sept. 2025)
ISBN Nos.: Hardcover: 978-3-031-87392-8
Softcover: 978-3-031-87395-9
eBook: 978-3-031-87393-5 

16/10/2025

_________________________________________________________

REFERENCES

Foucault, Michel (2015) The Punitive Society: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1972–1973 (translated by Graham Burchell). Basingstoke, Hants and NY: Palgrave Macmillan

Skornicki, Arnault (Author), Andrew Brown (tr.) 2025) Michel Foucault, the State and the Social Sciences https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-87393-5

_________________________________________________________

A Different Path

 

ALTHOUGH my potential journey to a PhD has been thwarted by insurmountable bureaucracy, I thought it would be fun for me — and perhaps for any interested readers out there in cyberspace — to document my route from my earliest encounter with my topic to (possibly) turning it into an academic monograph or even going the self-publishing route. The Introduction and first couple of chapters are already written although these will, undoubtedly, be revised and redrafted many times more along the way.

 Back, in what now feels to me like a long-distant past, but was in fact 1980, when I was twenty-one years old, my family had recently moved from the idyllic small town of Tring, in Hertfordshire, to the rather less pleasant (to put it mildly) suburban enclave of Harrow in Middlesex, north-west of the UK's capital. These days Harrow is referred to as 'Greater London', but is over an hour away from the centre by train — both overground and underground — and involves at least two changes; three if you want to go somewhere further from the city centre. About a mile and a half away from North Harrow lies the slightly more scenic village of Pinner, the pretty timber-clad houses along the High Street a reminder to its Tudor legacy. One train station away or about forty five minutes' walk, it is perhaps most famous as the birth-place of Sir Elton John and where he grew up and went to school. The house where he, allegedly, had ballet lessons as a very young boy was pointed out to me once. I am, however, unable to verify the accuracy of this claim. 

Pinner had, at the time at least, several charity shops which I would visit with some relish — not for the musty-smelling pre-loved clothes or dusty bric-a-brac, but for their eclectic selection of books. It was at one of these shops I first came across the work of George Mackay Brown. A slightly foxed but otherwise intact, copy of his volume of short stories, Hawkfall (1974) caught my attention. Reading the stories contained between its covers as soon as I got home I was intrigued. I was fascinated by Brown's simple, yet sensitive and uniquely lyrical depiction of hard-working farmers, fishermen and crofters. Who was this writer, residing in the distant Orkney Islands, that I had only the vaguest knowledge and understanding of at the time? I to find out more with an urgency that felt unaccustomed. 

As I discovered more and more about George Mackay Brown, the poet and writer as well as the man he was, I grew to have an ever greater affinity to him as a person and his traits although, as a writer, I sadly lack his remarkable gift for word-shaping and storytelling. Thus, with the unforeseen delight of that first collection of short stories purchased in 1980, began my preoccupation with Brown's literary oeuvre. It's an enchantment that will hopefully endure for the rest of my life. 

As for the mystery of that unfamiliar remote archipelago of islands, Dear Reader, I am thrilled to share that they became my home fifteen years after the story I have just told. I feel blessed, every day to have found peace and tranquility in this beautiful place, that has not only afforded me sanctuary from a past I'd rather forget, but has provided me with opportunities I never before experienced or imagined possible. 

I am pleased to witness the increasing number of authors who choose to address climate change in their fiction — for even in fiction there is always a grain of reality which gives the reader insight and pause for thought. As an independent scholar, not affiliated to any academic institution, I consider it a kind of privilege to be able to utilize the experience gained from studying for an MLitt in Literature at the University of the Highlands and Islands in 2012 – 2013 that affords me the ability to reason, research and write intelligently about a topic I feel passionate about. 

Just because I am no longer able to leave my home due to severely impaired mobility does not mean I don't want to support efforts to bring climate change under control, as much as it is still possible to do so at this relatively late stage. It is my generation's duty to ensure the sustainability of our planet for those who will follow in our footsteps. Sadly it won't make any difference to what is happening in the wider world, but in embarking on a new phase of my independent studies, I aim to build on my initial work on the Orkney poet and writer, George Mackay Brown (1921 – 1921), in which I shone a light on his first novel, Greenvoe (1972), exploring it from a Gothic perspective. 

My new phase of research will interrogate Brown's major prose works from an ecocritical standpoint, facilitating, specifically, further deconstruction of Greenvoe which, I believe, lends itself particularly well to ecocritism. It will also be an opportunity to consider his other novels in greater depth than I have before, as well as being a chance to address his position as a writer situated between two literary eras, those of the Enlightenment and Modernism and to examine how this influenced his output. 

Setting out my intentions publicly in this way will, I hope, serve me as motivation to accomplish my aims at some point in the future. Let's see how that pans out in the long term ....... 

16/01/2025

 ________________________________________________

BOOK REVIEW: Before Colonization: Non-Western States and Systems in the Nineteenth Century, by Charles R. Butcher and Ryan D. Griffiths (Columbia Studies in International Order and Politics)

Just like the effects of climate change, the colonization and subsequent collapse of states can be traced much further back in history than the common imagination is able to comprehend. As the authors endeavour to explain at the very beginning:

The field of IR [International Relations] has a problem. It is a field that aims to explain broad patterns in world politics, such as the processes of state formation, the nature and frequency of conflict, and how order emerges among states across a range of issue areas. To answer these questions, IR scholars have looked back into history to draw general lessons and construct universal theories. Yet for the most part they have examined one state system, the European system, which expanded to become the global system by the early twentieth century. But other state systems existed during this period that are less well understood.

In the volatile, uncertain world of the twenty-first century, then, the book is a timely reminder of how fragile states and nationhoods across the globe really are. A popular belief is that colonisation was always instigated by Europeans and, therefore, all of the world's states are Eurocentric in nature. That is not true, of course. There is a great deal of global diversity and this book presents a welcome new perspective on the topic.

The book is quite data-driven, explaining, often at length, the analytical models employed in collating the research and subsequent findings. Those readers less keen on statistics and more interested in the facts and history of colonisation and its subsequent collapse are encouraged to persevere. It will be worth their while. The discourse, explaining the differences and similarities between non-western states in, say, southeast Asia and west Africa and European ones in terms of religion, the economy, trade and judicial processes, is enlightening. About how states are governed, for example, the authors write:

Whether states are centralized or decentralized is the outcome of conflict and bargaining between rulers and vassals. Rulers are individuals who control the state, sitting atop the hierarchy as the sovereign. Vassals often control their own territories, appoint their own successors, keep their own military forces, collect their own taxes, and appoint their own officials but are constrained in their ability to make war and contract with other states and may send resources to the ruler as tribute.

The book defines the notion and functions of states, the different ways in which they were structured and worked as well as how they interacted with other governing authorities both inside and outside their borders. It explains that centralised governance involves the increasing encroachment of more bureaucrats and governors over the territory claimed by the ruler and the erosion of the vassals’ privileges, while decentralisation is less expensive and more flexible when military forces need to be mobilised or changes to the personnel in charge of a particular state have to be made. Most states in the nineteenth century and earlier began decentralized, only becoming more centralised by degrees over a period of time. The requirements of trade and war are the most likely factors to lead to centralised rule.

While borders in Europe and Africa and South Asia shifted repeatedly, those of East Asian countries have remained the same for centuries. Furthermore, due to the burgeoning importance of China and the West's desire to understand its culture, politics and functioning, the colonial experience lasted longest and the most intact in this region.

The authors discuss the various trade routes taken in countries across the Asian continent from around 1600 until the late 1900s, transporting everything from grain and cloth to gold and silver. In this and a few other instances the scope is slightly broader than the nineteenth century focus suggested by the book's tagline, probably with the purpose of putting particular topics into proper context. The authors elaborate, for example:

Although accounting for a small proportion of India’s precolonial gross domestic product, trading links with the Indian Ocean generated large cities, banking and financial institutions, as well as demand for education and public goods along the coast; as such, they were the staging post for the colonization of the entire subcontinent. For these coastal parts of India, the eighteenth century was a period of urbanization and expansion of monetary connections, with increasingly broad networks of clients.

One of the most fascinating and enlightening sections in the book — for this reader, at least — is that centred on West Africa. The authors outline the slow process of moving goods about by camel or donkey. Camels could travel twenty to twenty-five kilometres per day with relatively heavy loads, while donkeys and humans could travel about twenty kilometres with lighter loads. Although most production was for local subsistence and exchange at nearby markets, there was also a lively trade in gold, salt, and kola nuts. In addition there was an active slave trade. As the authors write:

The Atlantic slave trade, which peaked in the eighteenth century but continued “unabated” through the early and mid–nineteenth century despite being banned in the United Kingdom (the largest trader in slaves) in 1807. Slaves were abducted from the interior by indigenous state monopolies, merchant slave traders, and smaller-scale conglomerates and taken to coastal ports such as Ouidah (in modern-day Benin) or Old Calabar (in Nigeria) to be sold as slave labour in the Americas and the Caribbean. 

For centuries West African politics oscillated between rule by decentralized empires and fragmented city-states, some of which attempted unsuccessfully to introduce centralised rule.

Before Colonization is a highly scholarly, well-researched study of the birth and death of statehoods and their governance across Asia and West Africa, during the nineteenth century with occasional references to earlier periods serving to provide additional context. Due to the book's academic premise, there is a fair amount of repetition in which first the contents of chapters are outlined at the beginning, before being summarised at the end and repeated at the start and conclusion of sections.

In conclusion, the book's intended readership are academics in the field of International Relations, as well as scholars concerned with global social history more widely. It's very dense reading for significant stretches of the narrative but, as suggested in the body of the review, general readers who are not academics but who are genuinely interested in the history of states, their operations and ultimate decolonisation will find their persistence rewarded. This reader found Before Colonization fascinating, but admits that it might not be for everyone. 

Before Colonization: Non-Western States and Systems in the Nineteenth Century, by Charles R. Butcher & Ryan D. Griffiths (Columbia Studies in International Order and Politics)
Hardcover: ‎344 pages
Publisher: ‎Chicago University Press (8 July 2025)
06/07/2025

________________________________________________

BOOK REVIEW: Interrogation of Silence: The Writings of George Mackay Brown, by Rowena and Brian Murray

THERE are now several excellent academic studies and biographies available on George Mackay Brown, but still my favourite is, Interrogation of Silence: The Writings of George Mackay Brown (2004), written by the father and daughter duo, Rowena and Brian Murray. Its style sits comfortably between accessible and intelligently academic. The Introduction (Murray & Murray : 11) begins with a citation from an article Brown had published in Scottish Field Magazine, in August 1968, which sums up his character perfectly, not just as he was as a young boy, but as a lifelong persona.

"It was a dangerous world I had come into. I would never wander far from my doorstep. I would listen to the stories and poems and eat an apple on Sunday mornings and that was all and that was all the travelling in this world I intended to do. Already I was a word-wanderer; a seeker of images."

Each chapter covers around a decade of Brown's life, beginning with biographical notes setting his experiences and outlook into context, before addressing his writings during this period. Interrogation of Silence is the first study to examine Brown's conversion from Presbyterianism to Roman Catholicism. It does so only relatively briefly, however, and there are now other texts which delve deeper into Brown's new faith and how it impacted upon his writing, notably George Mackay Brown: The Wound and the Gift, by Ron Ferguson (2011), George Mackay Brown: No Separation, by Alison Gray (2016) and George Mackay Brown and the Scottish Catholic Imagination, by Linden Bicket (2017).

The authors take the reader on Brown's writing journey, from his earliest realisation he was good at writing stories to creating a comic-like magazine of sixteen pages called, The Celt that he distributed amongst his school friends, in which he wrote about football alongside stories. Following a very brief spell of working in Stromness post office, he was invited to join The Orkney Herald, to write opinion pieces. His weekly column, titled Island Diary, published under the pseudonym of 'Islandman', appeared in the Herald between 1945 and 1956. Besides his journalistic efforts Brown began experimenting with poetry, submitting some of his earliest poems to The New Shetlander magazine.

Each of Brown's major novels is treated to a brief plot summary and analysis of its main ideas and themes. Only a few short stories are discussed in any detail. There are quick run-throughs of the publications that fall outwith the criteria of poetry, short stories and poems. His collaborations with the composer, Peter Maxwell Davies (1934 – 2016), sadly receive barely a mention at all. The authors end the book by highlighting some of Brown's writings that were collated and published posthumously.

The original hardback edition of Interrogation of Silence is a beautiful book in every sense of the word. High-quality presentation, printed on good paper, its content was the most comprehensive biography on George Mackay Brown available at the time of its publication. Given that it's a quasi-academic study and the fact that Rowena and Brian Murray knew Brown personally, there is a surprising amount of conjecture, but that is a minor flaw in an otherwise largely commendable work.

Interrogation of Silence: the Writings of George Mackay Brown by Rowena & Brian Murray
Hardcover: 320 page
Publisher: John Murray Publishers Ltd; (2 Aug 2004)
26/11/2024

 _________________________________________________________________________

Friday, June 29, 2018

POEM: Ode to Libraries

Wednesday, 06 April 2022

A poem for the 26th annual American National Poetry Month

Ode to Libraries

As ancient as recorded time
temples of books, words,  
language, knowledge, collections;

hubs of reflection and wellbeing
for so many in this fractured,
fragmented world of ours.

Libraries, like churches, are places of
sanctuary, of escape, a temporary diversion
from the stresses of daily life;

they offer warmth, humanity, shelter
from the rain. Free books and respite;
a place to bide a short time are luxuries

not only for the poor and the homeless,
but for others too. Libraries are the
lifeblood of communities; like second

homes for those with no other means
to gain an education that extends beyond  
the basics of reading and writing. Books

open doors into other worlds; they show you
distant distinations, bring you nature beyond
your own home. They are portals to fantasy,

science, even the moon. Beautiful to touch,
to hold, books contain riches no other medium
can. Gold, silk or ivory bring none of the

glories of books. They are never unkind.
My life, for sure, would be less precious
without the presence of books in libraries.

© Carola Huttmann, 06 April 2022

 

Wednesday, May 16, 2018

BOOK REVIEW ~ DRAG, Wojciech ~ Collage in Twenty-First Century Literature in English

Keywords

Poetics, Politics, Art, Twenty-First-Century Literature, Experimental Literature, Collage

How to Cite

Huttmann, C., (2020) “BOOK REVIEW ~ DRAG,Wojciech Collage in Twenty-First Century Literature in English”, C21 Literature: Journal of 21st-Century Writings 8(1). doi: https://doi.org/10.16995/c21.1989

AS Wojciech Drag notes in this new study, Collage in Twenty-First Century Literature in English, collage is an act of violence followed by active repair (23). The initial deconstruction is the cutting or tearing involved in the making of a collage. The making good is the pasting required to create something new and to give it the ‘strangeness’ or otherness that is the definition of collage. For art or a text to qualify it has to be, at least in part, appropriated and be constituted of ready-made materials. These factors, in turn, must be juxtaposed or rearranged in some way that is different from their original state (ibid). The complexity of the resulting work demands from its audience a greater engagement than might ordinarily be the case so that intellectual sense can be made from it. In the light of this premise Drag quotes Rona Cran, who states that collage is an ‘invitation to participate’ and to be ‘experienced’ (21).

The fact that the book’s tagline is ‘Art in Crisis’ is significant. Already in his introduction, Drag explains how critics are lamenting ‘the death of the novel’ (Will Self) and the danger of print publications being displaced by electronic literature and audiobooks (5). The texts of each of the writers Drag discusses tell a story of a kind of crisis. In most cases it is of a personal nature: loss, grief, heartbreak, a subversion of the writer’s or main protagonist’s sense of self. Intertwined with the ideas explored, are also aesthetic, sociopolitical and cultural concerns of the twenty-first century: fashion, consumerism, capitalism and the influence of social media. Furthermore, it is the innovative manner in which these authors present their work, as fragments of appropriated quotations placed amidst lots of white space on the page, indicating conflict, hesitation and confusion, being joined together in alternative ways, which demonstrates the collage-like nature of what they have created.

Drag divides his study of Collage in Twenty-First Century Literature in English into three parts, bookended by an extended Introduction and a Conclusion. The Introduction is subdivided into sections in which Drag examines the history of collage in art and literature, the poetics of collage, the politics of collage, and the scholarly assessment of collage-like literary texts. In this section he also investigates the theories of multimodality, that is the way in which texts convey their meanings through semiotics. Finally, in his Introduction, Drag looks at textual coherence through Rhetorical Theory Structure (RTS), with its focus on author intention.

Collage, as an art form is believed to have been the invention of the Cubist movement with Pablo Picasso (1881–1973) and Georges Braque (1882–1963) regarded as the first exponents of the form. Drag explains that the term, derived from the French word, coller, to ‘paste’ or ‘glue’, can also be French colloquialism for ‘having an affair’ or ‘living in sin’ (10). This notion, then, of daring and co-existence is the theory behind collage. The Surrealist, Max Ernst (1891–1976), another advocate of collage, supposedly called it ‘the coupling of two realities’ (ibid). Made up of a series of nonsensical woodcuts with short subtitles, the first collage novel was Ernst’s book-length narrative, La femme 100 têtes (1929) (14). Drag describes collage as a product of the social, economic, aesthetic and philosophical conditions prevailing in the early twentieth century (15). In literary texts the ready-made element of collage usually takes the form of quotes or images, both attributed and unattributed. That is certainly the case in the texts Drag discusses in the book under review.

Collage has frequently been employed as a political vehicle. The anti-Nazi photomontages of the visual artist John Heartfield (1891–1968) are just one such example (25). The Russian avant-garde artists who flourished between 1890 and 1930 also used collage to promote their anti-capitalist sentiments (ibid). Less extreme, but equally forceful, is the use of collage as a response to the rise of consumerism – think of the work of Andy Warhol (1930–1987) and of some of the Abstractionists, such as Willem De Kooning (1904–1997), Jackson Pollock (1912–1956) and Mark Rothko (1903–1970) (26). To illustrate a literary example, Drag cites the American artist and critic, Gwen Raaberg (b.1932) as a prime proponent of writing about collage, not only in the context of visual art, but as having a place, too, in feminist literature (25). Modernist poetry, says Drag, depended on the fragmentary nature of collage far more than the novel. The most often cited passage of modernist poetry being the concluding eight lines of The Wasteland (1922), in which T.S. Eliot juxtaposes excerpts from seven sources (28).

All but one of the authors Drag reviews are American. Unsurprisingly, perhaps, the definition of collage – the idea of appropriation, use of ready-made materials and their juxtaposition to create something new – means that there is some overlap in the way these writers create their literary works.

In Part 1, subtitled ‘Art in Crisis’, Drag examines the late novels of David Markson (1927–2010). In his lifetime Markson created a rich oeuvre of work, but due to its unconventional, experimental nature his name only gained wider recognition after his death. Critics regard his last four books as a tetralogy, connected as they are by Markson’s method of cutting, pasting and juxtaposing fragments of quotes and random text to form their narratives (48). The books, all quite short – between 150 and 200 pages – are Reader’s Block (1996); This is Not a Novel (2001); Vanishing Point (2004) and The Last Novel (2007).

Drag analyses the nature and source of many of the fragments making up the four Markson novels he studies, attempting to explain their function in order to make sense of their meaning and purpose. About the last one cited in the previous paragraph, for example, Drag explains that it concerns Auden’s assessment of the German poet Rainer Maria Rilke (1875–1926) and is one of several hundred quotations Markson used in his narrative which are biographical or encyclopedic in nature (51).

Part II is titled ‘Society in Crisis’. In it Drag assesses two multimodal short stories by the experimental writer, Lance Olson (b.1956) and co-authored with the writer’s wife, Andi, from his collection, Sewing Shut My Eyes (2000) as well as two of Olson’s novels, Head in Flames (2009) and Dreamlives of Debris (2017). The author of fourteen novels, four collections of short stories and numerous instances of co-authored works of non-fiction, Olson’s writing has become increasingly collage-like over the last twenty years, incorporating hybrid black and white images reminiscent of graphic novels with the focus on juxtaposition and multimodality (99).

As Drag explains, the stories making up Olson’s collection, Sewing Shut My Eyes, came to be associated with the movement known as Avant-Pop which encouraged non-linear writing and is thought to have signalled the end of postmodernism in literature (100). ‘Telegenicide’, a short story from Sewing Shut My Eyes is concerned with the shallow nature of celebrity culture and is a comment on the influence of television on American society. It features seven top female models remarking on the pain they have to endure to keep their shape and the pressure the fashion industry puts on them. The accompanying images, or ‘panels’ created by Olsen’s wife, Andi, are finished off by Olsen with slogans taken from commercial adverts for Coca-Cola, Pepsi and the US Army. The panels show television screens in different contexts. One of them is an open mouth with white teeth which, Drag notes, ‘resemble plastic bags packed with cocaine’ (106). In his analysis of ‘Telegenicide’ Drag refers to the work of the French sociologist, philosopher and cultural theorist, Jean Baudrillard (1929–2007) and his essay, titled ‘The Ecstasy of Communication’, in which Baudrillard writes that ‘advertising invades everything as public space disappears’ (149). ‘Dreamlives of Debris’ is a retelling of the Minotaur myth and features forty characters, among them Sophocles, Plato, St. Augustine; contemporaries such as Julian Assange, Bradley Manning and Edward Snowden and mythical figures like Ariadne, Daedalus and Odysseus who, by way of appropriated citations, address themes which, Drag explains, are especially relevant to life in the twenty-first century: disease, cataclysm, chaos and conflict (115).

‘Head of Flames’, inspired by the murder of the Dutch film-maker, Theo Van Gogh by Muslim fundamentalists in November 2004, tells the story of his death in incomplete sentences from the view points of three narrators: Vincent Van Gogh, Theo Van Gogh and Theo’s murderer, Mohammed Bouyeri. These POVs are made up of quotations from Heinrich Heine, Strindberg and Julian Barnes and are occasionally interspersed with lines from popular songs, by singers such as Cher and Britney Spears (111). Olsen has Theo Van Gogh humming passages from Spears’ song ‘Hit Me Baby One More Time’ as he cycles to the scene of his murder (ibid). As in his short story, ‘Telegenicide’, Olson’s focus in ‘Head of Flames’ is on the anxieties that make up twenty-first century life, its traumas, discontents and the influence of social media (118).

Part III is titled ‘The Self in Crisis’ and is an assessment of Graham Rawle’s novel, Woman’s World (2006), which Drag calls ‘the quintessence of collage literature’ (159). Rawle is a British writer and collage artist whose visual work incorporates illustration, design, photography and installation. His series, ‘Lost Consonants’, which explored the comic effects of letters being omitted from sayings or quotations, appeared weekly in the Weekend Guardian between 1990 and 2005. Other series, such as ‘Lying Doggo’ and ‘Graham Rawle’s Wonder Quiz’, were published in The Observer, The Sunday Telegraph Magazine and The Times (ibid). His first novel, The Diary of an Amateur Photographer (1998), is a multimodal murder mystery comprising images, newspaper clippings and some cut up text placed in an envelope at the end of the book (ibid).

Woman’s World is a huge undertaking for which Rawle spent seventeen hours every day for five years cutting up women’s magazines from the 1950s and 1960s, finding single words, whole chunks of text and small images and arranging them to tell the story of Norma Fontaine who lives in a perfect woman’s world of handy tips and sensible advice. Whether it is choosing the right foundation garment or practising feminine allure through meticulous grooming, Norma measures her life, and the people in it, by the standards set out in the magazines she reads (160). Drag describes Woman’s World as ‘radical in its reliance on appropriation’, since it is ‘composed entirely of external elements’ (167). Ultimately, the novel represents an image of ‘the self immersed in, and defined by, consumer practices’ (170).

In the conclusion to Collage in Twenty-First Century Literature in English Drag points out that despite the similarities in the methods of creation and even, on occasion, in the content and sources used, each of the works reviewed ‘have been shown to vary in their incorporation of the collage principle’ (205). Drag reminds us that although the purpose of collage in art and literature during the second half of the twentieth-century was to shock and provoke its audience, in the last two decades collage has become much more of an artistic and aesthetic form of expression (208). Furthermore, advances in digital technology and the rise of electronic literature and ebooks have enabled the creation of more daring multimodal literature (209). More generally, each chapter ends with a comprehensive list of notes and works cited. Drag’s research and analysis of the texts he chooses to examine is meticulous and exhaustive. Writing in the first person imbues his material with a sense of ownership that is both bold and reassuring. The book also manages to be eminently accessible to non-academics interested in learning about the use of collage as a way of creating innovative contemporary literature.

Competing Interests

The author declares that they have no competing interests.

References

Baudrillard, Jean. 1983. ‘The Ecstasy of Communication’ (tr. John Johnston). The Anti-Aesthetic: Essays on Postmodern Culture, ed. Hal Foster, 145–154. Toronto: Bay Press.

Cran, Rona. 2014. Collage in Twentieth-Century Art, Literature and Culture: Joseph Cornell, William Burroughs, Frank O’Hara and Bob Dylan, 224 & 136. Oxford & New York: Ashgate.

Markson, David. 1996. Reader’s Block. Dalkey Archive.

Markson, David. 2004. Vanishing Point. Shoemaker & Hoard.

Markson, David. 2007. The Last Novel. Counterpoint.

Markson, David. 2010. This is Not a Novel. CB Editions.

Olson, Lance and Andi. 2000. Sewing Shut My Eyes. Black Ice Books.

Olson, Lance. 2009. Head in Flames. Chiasmus.

Olson, Lance. 2017. Dreamlives of Debris. Dzanc.

Raaberg, Gwen. 1998. ‘Beyond Fragmentation: Collage as Feminist Strategy in the Arts’. Mosaic 31(3): 153. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44029815?seq=1 (accessed 2 Feb. 2020).

________________________________________________________

NOTES

C21 Literature: Journal of 21st-century Writings is the journal of the British Association for Contemporary Literary Studies (BACLS).

It is an open-accss publication, made freely available under licence. The book review can be

read online: https://c21.openlibhums.org/article/id/1989

________________________________________________________

 

BOOK REVIEW ~ ALLEN, Paul V. ~ Eleanor Cameron, Dimensions of Amazement

Keywords

Place, Space Travel, Nature, Literary Criticism, Children's Literature, Fantasy, Feminism, Biography

How to Cite

Huttmann, C., (2020) “BOOK REVIEW ~ ALLEN, Paul V. ~ Eleanor Cameron, Dimensions of Amazement”, C21 Literature: Journal of 21st-Century Writings 8(1). doi: https://doi.org/10.16995/c21.1938

ALLEN’s book, Eleanor Cameron: Dimensions of Amazement draws on the hundreds of letters Cameron wrote, the notes she kept, and copies of her manuscripts, both of her published and unpublished work that make up her legacy. The result is not only an engaging scholarly study of one of America’s foremost female authors of children’s literature of her era, but is also an accessible read for non-academics interested in learning about the life and output of this author. Furthermore, Cameron was one of the first to write critically on the subject of literature for children.

Following a Foreword by the American children’s author, Gregory Maguire, in which he remarks on the timelessness of Cameron’s books, and an Introduction by Allen himself, the text is divided into fourteen chapters, each focusing on particular themes and preoccupations, personal and literary, that made up Eleanor Cameron’s life journey. Allen notes that Cameron was an only child born to English parents who had emigrated to Canada. The family struggled to find a financial foothold and suitable work, moving across the border, first to Minnesota, then Ohio and finally to Berkeley in California. Cameron’s father was a difficult man, unable to show affection, and the strain on her mother was significant. It was only after her parents divorced in 1922 that Eleanor’s life improved and she formed a close lasting relationship with her mother. It was a kinship that was to repeat itself in the lifelong closeness she enjoyed with her son, David, who was born in 1944. Eleanor had married his father, Ian, a printmaker and publisher, ten years earlier and moved with him to Los Angeles.

Framed by the backdrop of her personal story as context, the book is ultimately a study of Cameron’s career as a writer, literary critic and, in later years, as public speaker at schools, universities and conferences. Allen relates the writing process of each of Cameron’s books, giving a summary of their contents and describing the conversations, written and face to face, that she engaged in with her editors and publishers. Cameron, always very self-critical and forthright, wanted her books to be the best they could be and was determined to have a say in how they should look. One significant instance came at the beginning of her writing career. Unhappy about the photographs that had been taken for the back cover of her first novel, Unheard Music (1950), Cameron wrote to her editor at Little Brown, Dudley Cloud, asking him to ‘please destroy this book-jacket plate’. New pictures were taken, but in order to recoup the cost the novel did not run to a second edition (117). Cameron frequently sought out the illustrators for her books herself and occasionally fell out with the staff at Little Brown when they told her a certain artist was outside their budget (118). Cameron took good and bad reviews to heart and felt the pressures of marketing and how her books were received by the reading public (45).

Allen details, in great depth, the revisions Cameron made to her manuscripts, which alterations recommended by her editors she made readily and which were instigated reluctantly or even ignored. A particularly distressing episode of this nature involved the publication of Cameron’s first volume of critical essays, The Green and Burning Tree (1969). Emilie McLeod, who had taken over from Cloud as editor at Little Brown in 1950 wanted to omit two of the essays from the collection, ‘Dimensions of Amazement’ and ‘A Sense of Audience’, while Cameron was adamant that they should be included. Cameron further disagreed with the publisher about the cover, the endpapers that were suggested, the binding and even the type of paper to be used. She felt the publisher was trying to save money and so the period between August 1968 and March 1969 saw a lively exchange of correspondence between Cameron and Emilie McLeod. McLeod is said to have told Cameron: ‘My job is not to please you. My job is to sell your book’ (118–119).

Cameron’s friends were important to her and Allen talks about the friendships and acquaintances Cameron formed with other writers. Her best friend was Ruth Lipkis with whom she regularly corresponded. The letters, together with Cameron’s notes and copies of her manuscripts, are now in the Kerlan Collection, one of the world’s largest archives of children’s literature, held at the University of Minnesota. Other friends included the fantasy writer, Ursula K. Le Guin (1929 –2018), the children’s author, Lloyd Alexander (1924–2007), and the writer and publisher, Doris Gates (1901–1987).

Allen tells us that ‘Eleanor put all of herself into her fiction’ (xvi), so it comes as no surprise that Cameron readily plucked events from her own childhood with which to personalise her fiction. The Wonderful Flight to the Mushroom Planet (1954) features her own son and his best friend as recognisable characters. In her five ‘Julia’ books, written between 1971 and 1988, the protagonist is a young girl who wants to be writer and is largely based on Cameron herself. In the first book, A Room Made of Windows (1971), Cameron describes Julia’s struggle to accept her mother’s engagement to the man Julia was to call Uncle Phil. This is a direct reference to her own situation when Cameron’s mother remarried in 1924. Her stepfather, William Earle Warren, was a much kinder man than her father had been, but it took Eleanor a long time to appreciate it and acknowledge that her mother deserved to be happy and ‘was not created solely for her own convenience and pleasure’ (11). From the 1960s onwards Eleanor Cameron began to engage in literary criticism. Her essays were published in The Horn Book, a bi-monthly magazine dedicated to reviewing children’s literature founded in Boston in 1924. They were collected in two volumes. The first entitled, The Green and Burning Tree was published in1969; the second appeared in 1993 as The Seed and the Vision.

Cameron’s most high-profile criticism occurred in 1973, when she wrote a blistering critique of Roald Dahl’s children’s novel Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, published nine years earlier. Like the English children’s author and scholar, John Rowe Townsend (1922–2014), Cameron was critical of Dahl’s depiction of the Oompa-Loompas as African black pygmies. She felt it was in poor taste and indicated a decline in the quality of children’s literature. She further condemned the notion that sweets are nourishment, saying that the book, like the ‘brief sensory pleasure’ of candy, left the reader with little satisfaction (110). Cameron’s critique was published in The Horn Book and Dahl responded in the same magazine, accusing her of ‘enormous conceit’ (111). In the next edition of his novel Dahl’s Oompa-Loompas featured ‘rosy-white’ skin and ‘golden hair’ and were said to hail from Loompaland (112). Although Cameron is often credited with instigating these revisions, Allen believes that Dahl’s publishers had already planned them before the debate about the Oompa-Loompas erupted. Allen says Dahl was a morally complex figure who, although being a philanthropist and devoted father, had a dark side. He was an unapologetic anti-Semite and, in 1989, supported the fatwa against the writer, Salman Rushdie. He saw nothing morally wrong in the Oompa-Loompas being black slaves and denied there was anything racist in the original version of his characters (115).

Besides the six ‘Planet Mushroom’ books and five ‘Julia’ novels, Eleanor Cameron authored seven other children’s books in the period between 1959 and 1980. Her output also includes around thirty (uncollected) published articles, essays and book reviews. Despite her early determination to be a writer she suffered numerous rejections. In the end her persistence paid off. Late in life she was to write to a friend, ‘If one is a writer, then no amount of rejection is going to discourage or dam up the obsession’ (21). Without her contribution American children’s literature in the second half of the twentieth century would have been a very different scene. Her astute assessment and criticism, both written and verbal, ensured lively and vital debate among publishers and academics.

The only reservation in regard to Eleanor Cameron: Dimensions of Amazement is the book’s reference to source material. There are no footnotes or endnotes within the body of the text itself. At the end of the book there is a brief section headed ‘Notes’, listing quotes under separate chapter headings, but without sufficient citations to allow them to be followed up. This caveat notwithstanding, Paul V. Allen’s biography of Cameron’s life and work is a valuable addition to the existing scholarship on the subject of children’s literature.

Competing Interests

The author declares that they have no competing interests.

________________________________________________________

NOTES

C21 Literature: Journal of 21st-century Writings is the journal of the British Association for Contemporary Literary Studies (BACLS).

It is an open-access publication, made freely available under licence. The book review can be

read online: https://c21.openlibhums.org/article/id/1938

________________________________________________________

 

Tuesday, May 15, 2018

Book Reviews (2021)

DOESN'T time fly? Covid-19 notwithstanding, 2020 already feels like a distant memory. Now it's another year of great new books and reviews. Please find below links to the reviews I've written for Bookmunch during 2021. Click here for the ones I wrote in 2020 and here for those I wrote in 2019.

The Dust Never Settles, by Karina Lickorish Quinn

The Fell, by Sarah Moss

The Gap in the Curtain, by John Buchan 

Source: a saga, by Rosemary Johnston

Art of the Extreme 1905-1914, by Philip Hook

The Happy Traitor, by Simon Kuper
(the Extraordinary Story of George Blake)

Belladonna, by Anbara Salam

A Corruption of Blood, by Ambrose Parry

Dear Reader, by Cathy Rentzenbrink 

Island, by Siri Ranva Hjelm Jacobsen

Zennor in Darkness, by Helen Dunmore

Antlers of Water, ed. Kathleen Jamie

Winter in Tabriz, by Sheila Llewellyn

Summerwater, by Sarah Moss

I Know What I Saw, by Imran Mahmood

The Dead Girls’ Class Trip, by Anna Seghers

 Unquiet: A Novel, by Linn Ullmann

 Sisters, by Daisy Johnson

The Ghost of Frédéric Chopin, by Eric Faye

The Devil and the Dark Water, by Stuart Turton

The Stonemason: A History of Building Britain, by Andrew Ziminski

English Monsters, by James Scudamore

Valse Triste, by Marcello Fois

The Island Child, by Molly Aitken

The Great Fortune, by Olivia Manning
(The Balkan Trilogy, Volume 1)

The Spoilt City, by Olivia Manning
(The Balkan Trilogy, Volume 2)

Friends and Heroes, by Olivia Manning
(The Balkan Trilogy, Volume 3)
 

The Journey to the Mayflower, by Stephen Tomkins

The Paris Library, by Janet SkeslienCharles

 

The Fall of the House of Byron, by Emily Brand

 

Book Reviews (2020)

ANOTHER year and a great many fabulous books to read, review and love (or not). Please find below links to the reviews I've written for Bookmunch during 2020. The ones I wrote last year can be found in this blogpost. 
 
 
 

 



Book Reviews (2025)

For reviews from previous years, please click here: 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024.

Henry V, by Dan Jones 

Wild Dark Shore, by Charlotte McConaghy 

Heart the Lover, by Lily King

Orphans of the Living,by Kathy Watson

The Orange Notebooks, by Susanna Crossman

Shamiso, by Brian Chikwava

Atmosphere, by Taylor Jenkins Reid

The Blue Place, by Nicola Griffith

The Edge of Solitude, by Katie Hale

At the Edge of Empire,by Edward Wong

My Roman Year, by André Aciman

The Gentleman From Peru, by André Aciman

Night Train to Odesa, by Jen Stout

The House of Broken Bricks, by Fiona Williams 

Botticelli: Artist and Designer, by Ana Debenedetti



Book Reviews (2024)

A NEW year means more new book releases — they will be a mixed bag, I expect. Below are the reviews I've written this year for Bookmunch, run by the wonderfully enthusiastic Pete Wild. Thanks once again, Pete, for having me aboard.

For reviews from previous years, please click here: 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023.

Archimedes: Fulcrum of Science, by Nicholas Nicastro

Sergei Prokofiev, by Christina Guillaumier

On Shaky Ground, by V Domontovy (tr. Oksana Rosenblum)

Dylan Thomas, by JohnGoodby and Chris Wigginton

The Vaster Wilds, by Lauren Groff 

North Woods, by Daniel Mason

Anam, by André Dao

The Unbearable Lightness of Being, by Milan Kundera

Cairn, by Kathleen Jamie

Summer in Baden-Baden, by Leonid Tsypkin

The Burning Time, byPeter Hanington

The Hollow Mountain, by Douglas Skelton

How to Build a Boat, by Elaine Feeney

Music in the Dark, by Sally Magnusson

A Trace of Sun, by Pam Williams

Nightbloom, by Peace Adzo Medie

Restless Dolly Maunder, by Kate Grenville

Double Proof, by Martin Stewart

Finding Sophie, by Imran Mahmood

A Woman in the Polar Night, by Christiane Ritter

This Other Eden, by Paul Harding

 

 

About

  2026 is National Year of Reading      Carola Huttmann I AM a housebound writer, book reviewer, lived experience advocate and independent...